Mafia 2 or Dishonored?

Mafia 2 is very good, but overall Dishonored is much better, although a different genre.

Altough i am a great fan of Mafia II my personal opinion is that Mafia II is so short,great story though.Not sure how to even compare such different genre of games.With Dishonored you will consume much more time story is also great too,especially if you are trying not to kill but to knock out everyone that will take lots of time,other than that with all this being said its up to you,but if it was me i'd pick up both Mafia II can be bought for 1 dota 2 key thats like 1.90$ or am i wrong , Dishonored is however more expensive :).As for the Dlc's i'd say Mafia II dlc's are poorly exectued and Dishonored dlc's are far more superior , i suggest you check out games on youtube before buying or downloading.

Dishonored without question.

I'm going to have to say Mafia 2, because for me, Dishonoured sucked balls.

Why are you even asking this question? DISHONORED, no doubt about it.

Why are you even asking this question? DISHONORED, no doubt about it.

dishonored i four buying it from steam. you can probably get mafia 2 for really cheap off steamtrades

mafia 2 is the best game.

Dishonored if you are actually buying it. Mafia 2 is worth next to nothing in trades so you can get it for a couple tf2 keys and save money.

dishonored

Mafia was a real fun game!

Mafia 1...

dishonored

Dishonored is awesome.

mafia 1 > dishonored > mafia 2

Despite what everyone says, Mafia 2. Just for the atmosphere. Dishonoured is a steampunk Assassin's Creed, really.

I really like Mafia1 and 2, but after these comments, purchase Dishonored :3

Mafia 1 is Owner.

Mafia 2 is better in my personal opinion

dishonored no doubt

Dishonored all the way.
Mafia II is good, but not particularly great gameplay wise, but it's solid. it has a good Mafia story, not the best, but well written and the atmosphere is great, and you can die in car accidents, which is a cool feature...
now, Dishonored looks more interesting, not ground-breaking but it has some cool features, the fact of not being restrained by a 2M wall is great. the atmosphere is good too, the plague thing, the rats, the mass murder of whales...

if you enjoy GTA like gameplay with a good atmosphere and a well written mafia story, go with Mafia II; if you like steam-punk setttings, exploring and stealth with magic, go with Dishonored.

BOTH !!