Obligatory help me pick a game to play thread!

Go play Dust: An Elysian Tail, one of my favourite indie games.

play Saints Row 4 cuz it iz da bests

I see you've already tried Cook, Serve, Delicious! but since you only have 2 hours logged in, it might be idling... Anyway, I love this game! The gameplay is fast-paced but it's not really hard to get the hang of it. It's a lenghty game (about 30 hours to 100% it) and although it becomes a little bit grindy towards the end, it's still enjoyable because I think the audio and visuals are great...

Same thing for Legend of Grimrock, you've played it for only 1 hour. Is it because you don't like that genre? It's a really great game if you're into dungeon crawling and you like finding secrets. Also the sequel just came out (I've heard it's even better but still haven't bought it myself so can't really tell you...) so it might be worth getting back into it! It's also a lenghty game (I'd say 20-30 hours to complete and maybe 10-20 more hours to 100% it)...

Another is LEGO Lord of the Rings. GREAT GAME! You don't even need to be a LotR &/or LEGO nerd to appreciate it so that's a plus! Campaign averages 20 hours I'd say, but if you want to get all the collectibles, it can take up to 50 hours. The gameplay may be a little bit on the easy side but it's fun nevertheless! Visuals are surprisingly good (I didn't know what to expect of a mix between 'real' textures and LEGO textures, but the end result is great)!

Those are three of my favorite games and I really recommend them!

Edit: I hope you don't mind lengthy games! :P

Sad you don't have This War of Mine but I guess you could play XCom: Enemy Unknown (not sure if you have Enemy Within though). One of the best turn based strat games against aliens. Playing Tomb Raider again would be nice. Who wouldn't love Lara?

I'm not good at recommending, because most of time I can't even say why I like something, so here's what I found in your library with short useless commentary:
The Cat Lady - I've just started this one, it's interesting point and click with dark themes.
System Shock 2 - old, but awesome, still manages to freak me out
Shadowrun: Dragonfall Director's Cut - if you liked Shadowrun Returns this is even better (at least my best friend claims so, I haven't had chance to play it yet)
all Fallouts, especially Fallout 2 with Fallout 2 Restoration mod, but I love all of them
Bioshock - another my favorite you haven't played, contains nice plot twist

Saints Row IV, Witcher 2, Trine 2, Hitman Absolution, HL, GTA, Giana Sisters, Batman AA, AC, FEZ, Deponia etc.

One Way Heroics! Very original roguelike-style RPG, you can spend as much time on it as you want; beat it once and be done with it, or challenge yourself and discover more of the game's world.

Well, first of all, you should play your Payday 2 more often. They're constantly updating the game, adding features, skill trees, contracts and cross-overs with other games or movies and they just announced that they're gonna support the game for 2 more years. Sure they have tons of paid dlcs but you can skip them if you don't happen to like the guns or host games a lot. I've never seen such support from a developer before and considering that they're just 50 Swedish guys, makes it more interesting. Besides, the game is fun, no argue there.

I suggest buying one of the Magic: The Gathering games (anything besides 2015 when they turned it to giant money-sucking bullshit). The community may be less than it was before but the gameplay makes up for it. Reviewing the possibilities in your mind and turning the game in the last second with a huge comeback have made some of the most enjoyed moments of my gaming life.

Another AAA game that's worth more attention from you is Counter-Strike: Global Offensive. After playing mediocre FPS games like CoD and Battlefield (*grabs popcorn), I appreciate the spray pattern and the planning style of CSGO much more. There are limited number of paths to a target and believe it or not, it makes it more intense to decide which way and how to attack. If you happen to know certain maps and work well with others, you'll never get surprised because of some unrealistic abilities/skills you see in other games.

And Mount And Blade of course, once you get in, you can hardly get out. Enough said.

Hope I'd helped.

The batman arkham game series. I see you've played arkham origins. The other 2 games follow on from that ones story. The combat system is similar and amazing. If you liked arkham origins then you will definitely like these.

As for indie games Full mojo rampage is a great game. Its a rogue like game that has some persistent upgrades out of the game. It has an amazing soundtrack and beatiful graphics. Their is a lot of randomness and variety in the gameplay and there is many different characters to choose to play as. Since it is a rogue like game if you want to play it to completion you can except alot of hours worth of gameplay.

Just Cause 2. Read my review on Steam if you want, I'm too lazy to type how I love that game once again.

I'd suggest putting some time into Starbound. I find it a great procedurally generated sandbox. The amount of creativity put into it by it's developers is enormous and it can keep you playing for hours on end with enough content to give it a high replayability level. Personally, I find it more fun when played on co-op, but the singleplayer is just as fun, too.

Also, I see that you logged 54 hours in Binding of Isaac. Although it's not in your inventory, BoI:Rebirth is a great remake of it with bugfixes, added content, and more. I, personally would suggest it more than Starbound, but it wasn't in your inventory.

I loved all the Ys games, so give then a little more time, and if you want one that you can finish fast, play guacamelee, it's fun and short.

· The bureau: x-com declassified is a pretty decent game with a nice plot. It's basically the, now classic, cover based, Third person shooter with some nice twists. you command your team mates in the middle of the battle, telling them where to cover and what to attack. it's more action packed than the rest of the X-com games, but the gameplay is good enough to enjoy the story.

· X-Com enemy unknow/within is an awesome turn based strategy and it allows you a lot of freedom, it's just too much to explain in one reply.

· The darkness II: it has an awesome gameplay, really fun to play. nothing really complicated, linear FPS, but it's pure fun.

· Both Trine games, awesome plataform based games. the first Trine was recently updated to a new engine (the same that Trine 2 uses) and it's one of the best good looking games from the past times. decent puzzles, good gameplay (switching between 3 different characters).

· Gunpoint is an awesome indie tittle. i don't want to spoil you the fun, so, no description.

Oh damn you have so many good games not played at all. Here we go.

Penny Arcade's On the Rain-Slick Precipice of Darkness 1-3. Personally I've played only the 3rd one, but it's hilarious! The story is simple, but enjoyable, the graphics are oldie, but damn cool and the soundtrack is enjoyable.

Half-Life 2. I think I don't need to explain this one, do I?

Sniper Elite V2. The story is meh, you have to save a nazi good guy, then destroy some nazi stuff, then kill some bad nazi guy, bla bla bla... But the gameplay is awesome! The stealth elements are quite good(the only thing I could complain is that you can't shoot lambs(WHY!!!) and you can not use others people's shots to camouflage yours, which was possible in the previous game), the maps are quite linear, yet they are pretty large so you can sort of plan your strategy. The biggest point in this game is the sniping(which is quite obvious :P) but when you are about to shoot, you have to think about how the bullet flies, the wind, the heart beating. And then you have the X-Ray cam. So much awesome! And sometimes the shots you make can even surprise you(I have a lot of e.g. but you have to see it by yourself)!

Uplink. Hacking Simulator before it was cool. I can't really describe you what the game is about. Is basically create steam bots, add people in those accounts, send phishing links and be rich! xD Just kidding. It's a cool game, if you are really into computers and hacking.

What is with all these threads lately? I blame Psychoclown!

On a legit note though I'd play the following if you don't want a "AAA" game:

Arma Cold War Assault (seriously Cold War Era showdown between NATO and PACT on a dozen square kilometer Islands with Tanks, Infantry and Aircraft slugging it out all together, what is not to like?)
Endless Legend
Earth 2160 (Not the best of RTS games but a highly underrated one.)

Serious Sam HD: The First Encounter
You should play this game because you won it from our group and I wanted to win it too:P Kidding, but massive props for all that time spent with true classics:Baldur's Gate 1 and 2. I still need to finish my EE playthrough of the first one. I see you also spent a lot of time on FTL, many more than me, I own a drm-free version. It's a blash to play.

Looking through games we both own, I can see several I'd recommend in a heartbeat. It depends on how much you enjoy the genres though. My first major recommendation is Crusader Kings 2: First of all, it's probably got the best UI that Paradox has ever made for one of their classic Clausewitz engine games (EU, Victoria, HOI series, etc). Furthermore,whereas other grand strategy games are focused on developing your nation-state, CK2 is focused on developing your dynasty.The difference is vast; the latter allows you to take a more personal stake in an alternate history where your family line is the emergent factor. It can seem overwhelming trying to deal with a myriad things at once but once you've spent some time leading a tiny kingdom (a lot of people recommend beginning with one of the provinces in Ireland or Bohemia as a duke) and have played around with the map options it starts to make sense. There are a lot of events to oversee and a lot of decisions to make, particularly regarding your family in terms of succession and maintaining your hold on the throne. I don't know if you own the DLCS but when I first tried the game through Gamersgate (back when Paradox still owned them) I had the vanilla version and tried starting at the beginning of the Hundred Years War as England. Protip:Don't overtax all your vassals then call on them to raise their armies to defend English holdings in Ireland whilst you have as much sex as possible with mistresses.
The game is a definite timesink, although the "pause-and-play" aspect is nice because you can sit there for hours plotting moves before actually committing to anything. The ultimate armchair emperor game.

Disciples II: Gallean's Return-It's been called a HOMM clone but that isn't really accurate. Alright well...the setting isn't unique, the tropes are familiar, and the music isn't anything to get excited about but the gameplay, particularly tactics, is a huge step forward for the genre. You're focused on leveling not just a hero but also his small army of creatures. The game is almost more like leading an adventuring party that levels up as they fight monsters, gain treasure, buy and sell magic items, and advance the story. Just a word of warning, apparently sometime in the last couple of years it stopped working well with WIN 7 64-bit. I had XP the last time I played it and got a new laptop with 8.1 unfortunately so I've not tried to play.

I actually enjoy sharing my gaming love so let me see...

This is actually from my all-too-brief review for Mount and Blade:Warband
Cannot recommend this game highly enough. One of the most exhilirating and satisfying gaming experiences you will ever have. A glorious combination of deep combat mechanics, kingdom management, and sandbox roleplay, there's really no other game like it in existence.
The mods Floris Mod Pak, A Clash of Kings(still beta), and 1257 AD push the envelope and expand the gameplay in exciting new ways.

Hope these help.Game on!

The Lord of the Rings: War in the North.
Personally, I really enjoyed the loremaster gameplay and thought the story was pretty good - it reminded me of the epic story in LOTRO. Then again, I am admittingly a huge ME fan and may be a bit biased. I didn't find the other two characters quite as fun but I've always preferred jack of all trades spellcasters. I would also recommend playing it with at least one friend, since the AI does not exactly shine.

You cant go wrong with Secret of the Magic Crystal :D

Others than above recommendation,

I see you have Last Remnant, strategy JRPG hidden gem, although you need to play pass first boring part until you have full control over union and 12 union size where real fun gameplay begins, also check wikia for min-maxing and all quests for hardest final boss.

Van Helsing 2, I just finish it week ago, it's fun game, I feel it have more engaged ARPG games, gameplay and customization, more fun when playing with friend and heroics difficulty.

I see you have play a lot of FTL, you may interesting in Dungeon of the Endless, if you like on board combat with rogue-like, and tower defense with co-op multiplayer as a bonus.