Dishonored or This War of Mine if you want long games ... Tomb Raider is pretty awesome 2

The Vanishing of Ethan carter is good but not that long :/

MGS, while good, is really really short, so I wouldn't pick that one. Dishonored - GOTY is not worth it, what's added by the DLCs doesn't justify it costing 2-3x the base game, so I wouldn't pick that one either. Among the other four... Dishonored and Tomb Raider can't get much cheaper, while The Vanishing of Ethan Carter and This War of Mine definitely can reach 75% off in six months. Either get Dishonored or Tomb Raider. Also, with the money you'll spend on Dishonored GOTY, you can get Dishonored + Tomb Raider. I'd say Tomb Raider is worth much more than the Dishonored DLCs.
(voted for Tomb Raider because I found it slightly less boring, I get bored easily)

i likem all but take dishonored goty or the the one without the dlc is also fine

This war of mine is realy nice :)

I spent my last 5 euros today. Bought Hitman Absolution: Elite Edition. I regret nothing :D

all of them D:

Voted This war of mine. It's crazy it's not near the top. Great great emotional game :D

Definitely Dishonored, especially if you like replaying and perfecting games, Dishonored was made for that thanks to multiple ways to do shit. Also, very challenging if you're going for 100% achievements

This War Of Mine !

Dishonored - Game of the Year Edition, after all the second part is coming :) Or Tomb Raider, Lara is my favorite character since childhood.

Dishonored GOTY for sure, even though I LOVED Tomb Raider, buying Bethesda games and their DLCs separately will cost you way more than taking the GOTY edition...
So IMO you'd better take Dishonored GOTY now and Tomb Raider at the next sale ;)

bump... I choose tomb raider :)/ Hope you like the game.

Dishonored and tomb raider

If i were you, i would choose " This war of mine " between this list !

This War Of Mine. It's a unique experience and it has a lot of replay value. Because there's no scripted plot, you can take the game in any direction at any point, so you have a lot more freedom of choice compared to games where the important choices are all scripted. Also, the locations and the circumstances within them change with each playthrough, and you can play with different character combinations. They recently released a scenario editor, too, as a free update. The 2D presentation and mouse only interface may seem outdated to some people, I guess, but I think they fit perfectly in this game.

Dishonored GOTY! The DLCs are pretty expensive if bought separately so might as well grab that.