Sorry if this is the wrong place to put this but I don't know what to do, i had a giveaway for a game, the user won and i sent the key, they never marked it as anything, and i was worried they key hadn't worked since D.I.G screwed me over with some keys i bought from them, but i checked their profile today and they are now currently suspended. I just unsent the key but i'm worried the damage may already be done.

I know I can request a new winner, but I'm worried that they may have activated the key, and I don't want to re-roll the winner and then have to buy a new key for the game to give out, or what not.

what should I do?

7 months ago

Comment has been collapsed.

Ask the admins for a reroll

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Was the key marked as viewed by winner?

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

If there is a green eye icon next to the key, then the user saw it, and the key may be compromised.
If there is no such icon, it means that the winner did not see the key and you are completely safe to reroll.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Suspended winners are always eligible for reroll while suspended, and they'll likely be afterwards as well if the infraction for which they had been suspended was a recent (up to 1 month) not activated / multiple win. That would have been the best option, but you messed up when you unsent the key.

If you can be sure that the key was not marked as viewed before unsending it, or that the user was suspended at the time of winning, then it's safe to reroll.
You can check their library to see if the game is there, but even if it isn't, that's still not proper proof that the key is unused (they could have used it elsewhere).

If you cannot be 100% sure the key is safe, the most reliable option is to wait for the suspension to end, send the key to them, and hope they won't cause you trouble afterwards (because, yeah, there're bound to be a few troublemakers on this kind of site, and they're mostly concentrated in low level public giveaways).

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Unpopular opinion: Wait for their suspension to end, then resend the key and ask them to mark it as received. (Or, just resend it immediately so it will be there once they return, if they never saw it in the first place)
I am not sure if there is an easy way to see whether their suspension is permanent, but waiting a week or two hopefully wouldn't hurt you (I believe that's the standard penalty for a first time regular infraction)

While you have the right to reroll during a suspension, you do not necessarily need to make use of that right. (I've always found it kind of a harsh double punishment since the wins you get during a suspension are likely unrelated to the reason you were suspended in the first place.)

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

It is a bad rule.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

You can see on their profile how long they are suspended for. And yeah, this would be the nice thing to do.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

like others said, check if the key was revealed (eye icon = winner saw it): https://i.imgur.com/w0Q4wk9.png

if it's revealed, ask for "received feedback".
if it's still hidden, ask for a reroll.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I wonder if that icon still shows up if the key is un-sent?

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

maybe someone in support could enlighten us instead of having normal users guessing what's going on with the site. 😅

oh yes that was totally passive-aggressive towards support but i have no regrets 😁

View attached image.
7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Yes, this has always confused me as well. If I were support, this sort of thread would be the first to draw my attention, in order to clarify the rules or help other users.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Instead of guessing, we could figure it out with a bit of testing. We could find a game that someone owns but is still able to enter a giveaway for on SG (there seems to be a lot of these lately). Then have someone create an invite only giveaway and only send the link to that one person. When the giveaway ends, don't click the button to send the key, but have the winner check the key page and then see if the eye icon shows up. Then the giveaway can be marked as received since it is already activated on the users account or you could request to have the giveaway deleted and explain that it was a test.

I would think the eye icon is disabled until you click the "sent" button, but that is obviously just a guess.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

or cg could reply "this is how it works". 🤷

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

He could, but I almost never see him responding in random threads, so he probably doesn't spend a lot of time here reading discussions. I think we are on our own to figure most things out unless a support member knows for sure.

I don't mind if he doesn't want to dedicate a lot of time to the site anymore. He built a great site and keeps it running which is good enough for me.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I had the case when key had eye icon but I did reroll as the user forgot to check if he had this game before entering GA.

So from what I see eye icon = user have seen the key BUT we don't know if he used it or not.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I hope this can answer it: the eye icon appears for the sender only in the moment that the receiver clicks on the button to reveal the key. So it works like this: sender adds keys and clicks on circle to sent (there will be a "sent" message but no eye icon yet) and in that moment the receiver will see a rectangle to click on and see whatever the sender has put there => receiver clicks on the rectangle to reveal the key (eye icon appears) => receiver activates the key and clicks on circle to mark as received.
TL;DR:
The square for clicking and revealing the key (or link) only becomes available after the creator of the GA clicks on "send", because before that it's just a "-" sign. That is why GAs in which the winner gets a gift through Steam will never have the eye icon (because there is no link/key sent through SG, and the rectangle for the winner to click on is never created).

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sign in through Steam to add a comment.