What do you guys think of this?

I said some, not talking only about your group. What's the difference between saying a thanks and a long comment ? You're giving the game away, it's to make someone happy. People who join are happy to win they say thanks. They do not need to say a long comment like "Thanks you, i waited 3 years of my life to wait this game, because X reasons and i couldn't have it before because Y reasons, ............. ". Everyone is happy and they say thanks, why forcing them to do a long comment ?

Okay, then let that be. Just remove him from your little group and that's it. I think you're the jerk here for snapping a pic of this and posting it on the forums. Whether you know it or not, you ARE trying to feel better about yourself, and pointing him out to show how he's lower than everyone JUST because you think he is.
People appreciate every single thing they win, some just get desensitized to showing it, which is not a bad thing.

Have your little rules all you want, kick people for breaking them all you want, but don't go posting pictures here of people who didn't obey them.

No but really, censor his name. No calling out users.

Can't think of anything better to say? Very sad. Next time be more clear in what you want.

This is pretty much what I thought you'd say if I didn't refrain from pointing out what the guy said. When you get all logical on 13 year olds they show their true colors.

You rather have a thanks then that? Not sure I follow, if anything it was funny and he stated in the middle he wanted it for a while, don't be a downer. You asked what we thought of it, since we didn't agree with you you call people trolls, really is that necessary?