Help me decide

Really, nobody has any input on this? :(
Is it because I didnt include a GA?

Just saw this post, dont know what you like, but based on my personal preference I would recommend transistor. I never played it myself, but I played bastion, and if it is anything close to bastion, its awesome :)

I would go with Banner Saga, love turn-based strategy.
Halfway great.
Transistor is also great.
Stay away from MassiveChalice; screw DoubleFine.

The Banner Saga is great, but i don't know for the others, sorry..

The Banner Saga, definitely. Great story, turn based strategy (units) game, and how can you go wrong with Norsemen?

first time i actually hear someone talking about Halfway, didnt really know that game exists prior to this topic. But it does look interesting :o

Its not like you left us with easy decision, both Transistor and banner saga are awesome games, but very different too. From what i could see massive chalice was a really promising title too, but just like most newish games from Double fine, it feels somewhat unfinished (people complaining about, well lack of this or that which is normal for early access titles).

so its a toss up between transistor and banner saga imo so it comes down to personal preference really. Transistor for all thats awesome about it, doesnt look like something id personally enjoy so id go with banner saga, but thats because i like turn based games - maybe because my tiny brain has more time to react in turn based games? :P

Transistor.

The Banner Saga and Transistor are my 2 most favorite games. Both have the best voice actings/artwork and not too hard gameplay.
If I had to pick one, I would pick Transistor but I really recommend both of them :3

I have not played any of the games, personally, but The Banner Saga looked like a promising title. So my vote's on that one. Cheers.

Transistor, Banner Saga good
Massive chalice had nothing that grabbed my attention and I almost fallen asleep during the first fight :D I'd pick something else

Thank you all for your input. Seems that there is a clear winner, and a clear second. I will give it a little longer, but so far, it seems that I may be playing Transistor in the next few days.

Definitely Transistor (although I haven't played the Banner Saga, which looks pretty good too). Also, the winter sale is still on, so something else might come up. Alien Isolation went 75% new...

Transistor is AMAAAAAZING! Seriously, everything about it is perfect

haven't played any so can't give you a good answer sorry been tempted to the Double Fine Bundle 2015 with Massive Chalice in it though

Transistor is decent. how could you miss Winter Sale, it's your duty !!! :D

Banner saga i'd say. Thou Transistor is work of art too. If you can - get both.