What is your definition of a good SteamGifts profile?

In this order: 0 negative trade feedback*, all gifts are activated, polite person on forum.

*I know that there are some people who recieved undeserved negative feedback and are waiting for support to solve their ticket, but I'm not a robot

boobs avatar ! best profile

i don't have really any special thing to put someone on the whitelist
just if he/she/thing is funny, nice, and not a dick, probably i'm gonna put it in the whitelist

Maybe also WL people do who puzzles? I really like the work that they put in, but those people also tend to be people who comment a lot anyways.

i am a bad person but i also started to recognize generous gifters and asked myself the same question.
well personally i add people that are active and giving but also that are funny and entertaining.

whoooom! and gone!

Thanks for all the replies. I made some adjustments to the criteria. So...

Factors that potentially contribute to a good profile and make a user worthy of whilelisting:

• Active in the forum and writes good comments (interesting, insightful and/or helpful)
• Level 1 or higher
• Activated all games won; has no multiple wins of the same game. In other words, passes the Steamgifts tools tests
• Good ratio. Ideally sent more than won, but not a must. In general the better the ratio, the better the profile.
• Created recent giveaways (in the last month or so), at least some of which are public
• Giveaways include unbundled and highly acclaimed games. Definitely not a must, but very much appreciated.
• Registered more than a month ago
• Says thank you after winning, and doesn't take ages to click Received.
• Untainted trade ratio (but if the number of negatives is low I will have a look)

it's all about having an awesome avatar! Just kidding. I agree with your two clear cases (good giver, quality poster) and that it's tough to make a call on the middleground. Activated wins, not acting immature on the forums, something close to an even balance for give/win... all really a personal call, really.

Well, remember that Whitelists aren't a fixed list, so you can always add or remove people as you see fit.

I tend to add people from the forums that I've enjoyed chatting with, that also have at least a balanced ratio. For a span of a couple of giveaways, I added anyone who actually read and responded appropriately to my posts in the previous giveaways (I demanded pictures of clowns/spiders/baby animals or asked people about food). Basically, people that are here for more than just winning games.