Using a honeypot GA to identify and suspend bot accounts...
They may become annoying like those thread-like ads on reddit, and it will be easy to tweak the bot around them unless they do something special with the programming, but I'd be interested to see how many they'd catch initially. I remember there was a necro thread about a large number of accounts being suspended for botting. I don't know how they caught them, but maybe they could do another similar raid.
Comment has been collapsed.
Enhanced SG offers a button to enter GAs straight from the list, so that's a really risky way to filter out bots.
I would rather suggest one of the following:
Edit Or just make a fake announcement and see which users stop using the site waiting for an updated bot ;)
Comment has been collapsed.
I actually love the first one. No humans get affected, only bots.
Comment has been collapsed.
I feel like it's pretty easy to tell on the backend who's using a script due to the speed of entering, uniform times between entries, and other patterns of entering. Having a honeypot might just catch people who didn't read or couldn't understand (like if English isn't their first language) the description. You can easily see someone comment multiple times on newly created giveaways within milliseconds of each other.
Comment has been collapsed.
It's funny that you point out the issue of English not being a user's first language in some cases, as I suggested in the original post that the GA description be in 8 or 10 languages.
Or maybe you are just proving that even people who can read simply don't! 😉
Comment has been collapsed.
I used English as an example. There are more than 8-10 languages being spoken here as first languages. Things can easily get lost in translation.
Comment has been collapsed.
AFAIK, currently for the first offense botters get just a temporary suspension, not a perma ban. If this is still the case, then the policy seems to me more like an invitation "feel free to use bots until we catch you for the 1st time (and that will most likely take a long time)", than an attempt to catch bots or to get us to investigate and report suspected bots. Correct me, if I'm wrong, please.
EDIT: Then still the problem is, that using some sites you can get to a high level for just a few bucks, buying newly released games with keys dumped there at 1% or less of their nominal price. Even if those are eventually added to the no-CV list, this usually takes a long time, and still makes maintaining a high level account incredibly cheap. What we would really need as the 1st step, so the people would even care about loosing their accounts, is adopting the same approach as Steam, and not giving CVs for GAs which are not giving +1 on Steam until they possibly reach the +1 status.
Comment has been collapsed.
Comment has been collapsed.
This suggestion sounds eerily familiar. I could've sworn Fitz10000, Fitz10001, Fitz10002, Fitz10003, Fitz10004, Fitz10005, Fitz10006, Fitz10007, Fitz10008, Fitz10009, Fitz10010, Fitz10011, Fitz10012, Fitz10013, Fitz10014, Fitz10015, Fitz10016, Fitz10017, Fitz10018, Fitz10019, Fitz10020, Fitz10021, Fitz10022, and Fitz10023 have all suggested this in the past.
Comment has been collapsed.
9 Comments - Last post 23 seconds ago by pb1
15,199 Comments - Last post 24 minutes ago by BBR
5 Comments - Last post 31 minutes ago by Audity2000
1,253 Comments - Last post 37 minutes ago by YunieRozier
6 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by pb1
336 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by VahidSlayerOfAll
1,965 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by NazaSekh
21 Comments - Last post 53 seconds ago by celeir
101 Comments - Last post 5 minutes ago by NoYeti
230 Comments - Last post 22 minutes ago by DreamSoulshine
36 Comments - Last post 23 minutes ago by amusedmonkey
27 Comments - Last post 24 minutes ago by Lachdanan
76 Comments - Last post 29 minutes ago by Empyre
2,583 Comments - Last post 30 minutes ago by KPopPoyehavshiy
I wonder if it would be possible / worthwhile for the admins to make a GA page that very clearly states, "This is not a give-away. Any account that makes an entry will be suspended." in 8 or 10 languages. And then suspend those accounts for a month or six or something. I expect that only bot accounts would enter, and then those accounts would be temporarily cut off.
Or, would this hurt the site's income?
Comment has been collapsed.