[WARNING] Humble Choice Resumes Itself The 1st !

If you weren't charged anything on the auto-charge day April 26th, it wasn't resumed. Again: contact Humble support if you feel something is wrong.

My guess would be that the status was reset a bit early for the upcoming May choice, but as long as they didn't charge you any money for it, which they already would have done on April 26th, there is no actual problem.

"Skip a month" button displays even if you already paused the current month.
I just checked after having paused earlier this month.

I don't know that the credit stuff matters.

This seems to come down to 2 things:

What the button says when viewing games list. If it said "Claim Now" instead of "Reserve Now" despite having paused, then yeah that's weird, and seems like an issue with the site to me.

What the banner says at the top of the page, if it displays at all. If it didn't appear like before or it says something suggesting that you didn't skip or pause, then that's a site issue or a verbiage issue with the site.

Either way, a good thing to tell Humble Support about.

So long as it's properly showing "Your next billing date is May 31, 2022", then a "warning" isn't needed. It'd certainly demand one if that date wasn't correct. Otherwise, as others have noted, it really doesn't change anything in any meaningful way. That said, it's definitely something that easily solicits a kneejerk reaction, and humans are prone to misinterpretations on simple data elements (eg, numbers, dates), so it's not really anything to criticize you for even if you did jump the gun on the association.

For reference, in my case it did unpause, but is also showing the correct billing date.

The same thing happened to me and I have paused April last week ...

If there are no significant problems with your account, you should in fact be able to still select April's games, as that'd indicate things are working properly. It'd actually be indicative of an issue if you weren't able to select the current month's games before the month switches over.

Functionally, autopay for Humble works the same as autopay for your bank (assuming you're utilizing the US bank system or an equivalently structured system), or the like. You can still use your bank account for the present month regardless of your autopayment settings, even to pay the same service provider as your autopayment is configured for, even if your autopayment date is changed (eg, such as being pushed back due to overlapping with a holiday). The only concerns with Humble autopay- as with your bank autopayments- should be in confirming that it's not autocharging you twice, or early.

To put that more simply, the autopayment doesn't connect to the status of the bundles themselves, despite being intended for them. You're still in the month of April, and its associated bundle, even if your autopayment date is not. Again, that's assuming nothing substantially broke or was significantly misconfigured on Humble's end, in which case you might be noticing issues in being unable to make purchases, or similar. Even then, it'd more likely than not be an issue fixed once things transition over to the next month, as such programming parameters are generally very basic and written over as needed.

Well yes it was unpaused, but I did not check whether or not I could have selected any games. My guess would be, that as soon as I tried to select any game it would take me to billing. I'll never know for sure, because I paused it right again seeing your post here. I've just checked - it's still paused, so I suspect the auto-resume for they May bundle just happened a bit too early. I'll check again before the auto-charge, just to make sure that I'll stay paused, because I don't want the April or the May bundle.