Amnesia , dark messiah

I would go for
a) day/night: Dark Messiah and add-ons to HL1
b) only night: Amnesia

gamz

Dark Messiah and Psychonauts.

:)

Ricochet or Garry's Mod

Definitely Dark Messiah and Amnesia. They're both fantastic games, especially DM.

Amnesia and AvP.

Company of Heroes/Shank are both great games you should give a try to.

Shank. You can finish it in a few hours

Reallife 1.6

Psychonauts.

And Dark Messiah.

Osmos is OK too.

DEFCON, because its cool.

Amnesia, Half-Life: Blue Shift, Half-Life: Opposing Force and Shank.

fap-fap

Psychonauts, Company of Heroes

Psychonauts, Dark Messiah.

Amnesia

What I do is assign a number on each game and roll a diece. If there's a game I have to play but don't want to, I just give it number one and roll 2 dices.

From that collection, I'd play Amnesia.

BTW, are you at some point actually going to count which game has received most suggestions and then play it?? I'm just curious to know.

Psychonauts or Dungeons of Dredmor or Company of Heroes or Dark Messiah of Might & Magic. It depends really.

Amnesia, Psychonauts, Dark Messiah, or... even Midnight Club 2.

I really enjoyed the stupidly absurd fun of it back in the day, but I admit I have no idea how well it's aged. I haven't played it in quite awhile.