A good deal or too good a deal?

100%.

nope.

Yep.

Most likely not. Check SteamRep etc?

Tell him to go first.

And yeah, check his SteamRep, but if it doesn't say anything it doesn't necessarily mean he isn't a scammer.

0 rep

What was the lowest discount Skyrim had?

I'd be more concerned about a chargeback if the game was bought using a stolen credit card. I think that's more likely in this case than not giving a key at all.

He has a key code.

It seems very fishy. He refused to go first no matter what.

And Russians can't use Paypal on Steam. Paypal is useless for him. So why would he want Paypal?

My guess is that this guy is a total scam, who wouldn't trust a 50+ rep trader, he refuses to go first in any cases.

Could be easily carded game. No.

He is the one pushing the trade, and yet he refuses to go first. I would reject the offer based on that alone.

Update: It looks like he got -1 rep and the thread was closed, scammed someone.

Reject. Skyrim + DLC for $10... I haven't even seen Skyrim vanilla for $10.

I can smell the tuna scent of that thread even here.

fishy

Seems Legit
His Profile

Too cheap to be true e_e

He did it for $5. And because of this he can forget about ever showing up on Steamtrades.

The scam is real.

"Well, sadly yeah ;| First time get scammed so I think it's a tuition fee of $5 for too trusting people without enough proof~ Took the leap of faith and fall flat on the face lol
Didn't feel too surprised or broken-hearted tho', somehow I knew it's too good to be true but well, I didn't realize that people could go so low as getting $5 for a ruined reputation :P

Looking at the reports at steamrep somehow made me glad I was not scammed for large sum of money, like $120 or more ;) "

Few days ago a guy offered me the following for Skyrim key: Bioshock Infinite, or Metro Last Light, Rome 2 TW! I checked his steamrep and saw him trade banned. Sounds too good to be true? It usually is. :)

sigh

Who the hell keeps falling for this? :/ Wasn't it just a little bit obvious?

He gave the guy he scammed negative rep, Classy

Someone should report him on steamrep. Or at least the guy who got scammed should.