So, I will go ahead and paint the target on my back for you: I am a U.S. Republican. There is a childish tendency in our country (from both sides) to attribute motive to someone's political stance (e.g. that someone believes in certain tax policies because they hate other groups to which they don't belong, rather than because of a differing stance of the role of the government in our lives), but let's try not to do that here. Inevitably some people will, but let's give it a try.

Here's the other part of my background that is relevant: I am a college professor. I've been at several different universities (public and private) at different stages of my career, but it's pretty consistent that there are far more professors on the political left than on the political right. Now, we are all free and welcome to hold our own political opinions, but there are some problems that I have run into with this recently. Generally, for a given issue in any group of people, there is debate or discussion as to whether we can come to a common ground in our standpoint, then decide on what policies to enact based on a common understanding. However, there has recently been an assumption that we are all on the same page in what we believe, and things skip straight to how we achieve goals that serve these purposes. For example, we recently had a faculty meeting at my institution to discuss how we can enact social justice on campus, without really discussing first what we mean by that and whether we can all agree that the goals of doing so are in line with our role as an institution and as professors. In my interactions with my colleagues (and don't get me wrong here-- I love my colleagues dearly as fellow people), I have only run across one other Republican who is currently at my institution. I personally feel that being a professor does mean freedom to express ideas, but that it is an abuse of power for me to make students feel like I am pushing my agenda and that their grade depends on agreeing with me, regardless of what side of the fence I lean.

However, it seems to me that higher education is celebrating increasing diversity of demographics, but decreasing diversity of thought. I no longer feel like I am able to freely express my dissenting opinion. Even if they are just outliers, there are professors who are losing their jobs in response to voicing unpopular opinions. There are protests going on all over the place, and it can be scary to make your opinions public when there are groups of people assembling and shouting that you are a Nazi for having a different opinion and that violence against you is justified. I apologize if I am just s***posting or starting fires, but I thought I might see how this community views higher education. Do you think it has gotten out of hand, or am I fighting windmills and chasing shadows? I'd like to hear what people outside of the institution think.

6 years ago

Comment has been collapsed.

Has higher education in the U.S. become too politically one-sided?

View Results
Absolutely. Academia cannot reliably cater to students of all beliefs if the institution favors one.
Maybe a little, but there is still room to express yourself.
I don't care.
College is a waste of time and money.
You're just being paranoid, old man.
No, I think that it is natural for a university to be more liberal than the general public.
No, I celebrate the fact that universities embrace progressive ideals.

Hey OP, if you haven't left already:

I have a serious question for you: Because it seems that you just realized this now, or at least very recently.
At least that is somehow the impression I got.

I don't understand this.. seriously.
I mean, Heterodox Academy has been founded when? I think 2015... too lazy to look it up, but I think that's roundabout correct.
And they have been mocked for being late to the party..

Of course, higher ed is totally fucked. Harsh way to phrase it, but it's true.

6 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Of course colleges/universities tend to be less conservative and more liberal

Conservative "a person who is averse to change and holds to traditional values and attitudes"
Liberal "open to new behavior or opinions and willing to discard traditional values"

Conservativism is about maintaining the status quo, whereas liberalism is about seeking to challenge the status quo (with the goal of making things better)

Academia is "the environment or community concerned with the pursuit of research, education, and scholarship."
Academics are not only exposed to, but often specifically seek out and explore new ideas, which in and of itself is more of a liberal pursuit than a conservative pursuit.
note: not saying conservatives can't be academic, or aren't looking for greater knowledge, etc., just that the whole concept of academia aligns itself more with the liberal mindset than the conservative mindset

6 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

There are definitely some problems with speech being repressed at US universities, and probably the best example is pro-Palestine activists, as has been reported heavily. I don't think it's a question of "left vs right", since there are clearly examples from both sides. Aside from Palestinian activists, there have been a number of high profile academics (ex., David Graeber) or guest speakers (ex. Chelsea Manning) that appear to have been treated unfairly by administrations that are overly concerned with trying to cultivate the "brand" of their school rather than foster free discussion.

6 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Right leaning people: "Lets think and talk about this and work out solutions."
Left leaning people: "IF YOU DON'T AGREE WITH ME THEN YOU'RE A RACIST-PHOBE-IST AND NAZI!"

There is clearly a problem not just in the differences of ideologies, but the approach to expressing them. It's difficult to discern where this originated and how to resolve it. Particularly when only one side is talking about it while the other is just screaming and resorting to violence.

6 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sign in through Steam to add a comment.