Less than a day until the sale ends... which of these games to buy? [UPDATE: Made the decision]

If I was about to buy something from this list I'd buy Prototype cos my nephew wanted to give it a try too and his going to visit me in a couple of weeks :P For myself I'd buy either Metro bundle or Pony Island :)

hmm... Dex is really cool, Ether One looks interesting and is one i'm considering too, dunno about lost Horizon, Metro is a legit af shooter (apparently, i didn't play it much because didn't run so well on my meh system), Pony island looks cool but is so cheap... Prototype is fun and would no doubt be worth it (if you've a controller), i really enjoyed RAGE but i played it at launch
...i voted for Prototype (but be warned that there was recently a remastered edition released for console, no telling if will come to PC and if it will be a free upgrade if it does)(otherwise, would vote for Dex, Metro or Ether, in that order)

Wow ... tough choice, and several different genres, too. :X

It's really a mood thing for me, and they're all great games, but I'd have to go with the Metro Redux bundle. Those games really stand out above the others listed, IMHO. Story, immersion, gameplay , value per dollar ... yeah, they're my choice.

Out of these i'd say Metro. Brilliant game still.

I voted for Metro, but if you have spare money, Rage is excellent, not Metro excellent, but excellent nevertheless.

Get Pony Island - I just got it for myself few hours ago ;) plus as it's cheapest one you can still get othewr game from your list with it ;)

If you do Ether One, share your opinion on... something about it.

I've tried to play Metro games but they seem way too boring, no space for your choices.
It's just completely out of your hands, you just walk through the game, shooting monsters or people and that's it, not my type of a game, I guess.
I consider these games just a version of Counter Strike, only with bots.

Currently I have these in my basket:
Styx
Soma
Invisible Inc + DLC
Age of Empires Legacy Bundle (I already have part of it)
Memento Mori 2

Thinking if I should replace smth...

I chose Dex. I bought a copy for myself a while ago (also got the Soundtrack DLC), and will hopefully find time to play it sometime soon. It really looks fun!:)

Go Pony Island. Just don't expect it to keep you busy for too long.

I don't know any of these, so I'm sorry I can't help ;)

Honestly, Metro Redux Bundle is the best option out of the list you gave. Even though you already have the original Metro 2033, the Redux version shines more on 2033 rather than Last Light (people complaint that it mostly look the same). Anyhow, you can't go wrong with the purchase. The single player experience is just amazing!

Buy the Metro Redux bundle, forget the rest (they'll get cheaper soon).

PS Buy Metro bundle.

Dex and Ether one looks really cool, Metro and Pony Island is also looks like a great choice. Lost Horizon... I had it wishlisted, but still not sure if it would worth picking up (at any point with my backlog) ; Prototype has a super awesome story that unfolds sadly a little too slowly, and majority of the gameplay is breaking stuff and beating up thousands of various enemies, with a stronger foe sometimes + story bosses. Consider it a sandbox game with good story, better approach than taking the story as etalon and sub-par gameplay compared to that.
And RAGE.... started it. Runs really well even on my okayish laptop, shooting is nice, but it annoys me out of the world how much of a console game it is - overly smooth movements, very few interactive spots, and while there are paths and roads, you literally can not go further than 2 steps from them, the world is extremely closed - after borderlands 2, I felt the game to be a cage compared to it. If you can get past this aspect and the lukewarm start, it may be a good game (Combat is fine, world building is awesome, it's how the game plays in the word that's not really up for my liking, have to give it another shot)

Metro Redux Bundle is best option in my opinion :)

Voted Rage, but Dex and Pony Island are up there. Thanks for the GA :-)

If you haven't played the old Metro, why would you buy the redux? (unless you already know you'll like it)
Pony Island for meta stuffs (like Stanley Parable, Beginner's Guide, etc)
Prototype for mindless fun. It's like the Hulk game, run, jump, fly across building while wrecking everything around you.

If you are thinking about Ether One, get Infra instead!
I know I only making it worse but please consider it :)

This is what I like - Metro Redux Bundle > Prototype > Rage > Dex > Not interested in others!

There's one thing I didn't like in Metro 2033 - so many scripted events.

Metro is awesome
Books are great too

Pony Island is awesome! It is indeed 2-3 hours long, but worth every minute :) I won't tell you anything about the game, because it's best if you know nothing about it before playing ^^