Help me choose what to play next! [Lvl 3] [new ga's added]

Guardians of the Galaxy is well written and very funny. A great game if you are looking for humor.

Death Stranding ended up being a super relaxing game for me. Making deliveries, building roads, making my routes better. Recommended if you like completing tasks.

Batman Arkham Asylum is one of my favorite games (with Arkham City in my top 5 of all time). Play this if you want to be Batman and send bad guys to the hospital.

Depends on what you are looking for:

• VA-11 Hall-A: It is a game with rather low gameplay elements and I wouldn't describe it exactly as story-heavy as it mostly orientates around Jill and her customers as well as their relations. You are mixing drinks and have some minor influence on outcomes by doing your job properly and determining how much alcohol a drink should have. But overall, the game is very recommendable because it is simply a feel-good-game. After you finish you will simply feel better. Even the bad ending will make you smile.
• Okami HD: Very very long game and the start is awfully slow until you are finally in the actual game action-wise and head-wise. But after that it is an unique experience in graphic, design and gameplay that most people remember fondly. But as said, it is very long and also the talking might get your nerves after a while. Lots to read to.
• Guacamelee: Better in Co-op but also fun playing it alone. A 2d brawler centering around the mexican luchadores and the realm of the dead with some nice humor, some references and great controls. However, has some evil platforming parts if you have issues with that. Although most of these are optional if you go full achievement or good ending.
• Spyro Reignited: It is a nice game and on the lower challenge side. Also, this are basically three games in one and while the gameplay slightly changes over the course of the games, it might feel repetitive after a while. Especially if you join the collect-a-thon for the achievements.

Fahrenheit: Indigo Prophecy Remastered < short but great game
Okami HD and crash > MUST play
Double Cross < nice inde platformer
The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky < if you love jRPG (is great choose in time of sickness)

From what I've played, I recommend:

Binding of Isaac: Rebirth
Hades
Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines

BoIR and Hades are both fantastic roguelites. Maybe for different reasons. If you want something snappy and shorter, Isaac has you covered. Hades gameplay is closer to an ARPG.
Bloodlines is just a great RPG, even though it's very buggy. Make sure to install the fan patch, which is still being updated to this day.

The games I've tried enough to recommend to play are:
Superhot
VA-11 Hall-A: Cyberpunk Bartender Action
Avicii Invector
Hades
Ken Follet's The Pillars Of The Earth

Inscryption is amazing and Phoenix Wright is also really good but just a lot of reading. I wasn't the hugest fan of 911 Operator, so wouldn't really recommend 112 Operator.

A lot of these look really good and are in either my WL or library. Seems like you're really into detective games as well so I would prob recommend one from that genre.

I would've suggested either Sunset Overdrive or Kentucky Route Zero but since you have playtime in both of them, I'd say go for Okami.

I am a Marvel fan, so the first two games from your list, I would say.

Can't decide between Control and Arkham Asylum. Both are awesome, but I think Control has the way better gameplay. Asylum on the other hand has a better story.

I think you copied the wrong link for Caveblazers, unless it is meant to be a puzzle, but I don't see anything that looks like a puzzle.

YESS! So glad that you're enjoying Arkham Asylum! One of my favorite series of all time ♥

Hades by far. I dont think words are even enough to show why everyone should at least try it, as a bare minimum.

Great to hear you starting on Batman, but seriously, there's a lot of very good games on that list. I would say any of the listed top 10 is always an awesome choice. Have fun!