I hit the jackpot! Thanks steam!

My brother got a copy of the Orange Box for doing the first achievement. He only owned TF2 up to that point, so he did pretty good. I've gotten just coupons and coal, BUT I traded some of them for a copy of Fable: TLC. Yeah, was only $2.50 at time of trade, but who cares. Free game! LOL :)

so where is this gift in payday? can we find multiple gifts? It's part of the achievement, isn't it?

Gratz. Why I don't get a gift? :( I have like a milion coupons.

Todays crafting magic: Altitude and Quake IV

I got Cogs and Back to the Future Complete (I love both.), 50% Roboblitz, plus I crafted a 50% X-Superbox from seven coals (It's a pretty good average for completing 12 achievements.).

Woooow! Nice!
I got Devil May Cry 3 Special Edition in my first achievement. :P

I completed 11 achievments and all I got was Portal and Coupons -.-

Got 66% off protoytpe coupon for writing a crappy review.

i crafted my 7 coal into a -20% Codemasters coupon :(

don;t think anyone has my legendary luck, but i crafted L4D thrice in a row.

Congrtats!

I got 3 coal and a 50% off Oddworld coupon.

Till now I got FEAR Complete PACK, Portal 2 Lot off Coals & Coupons ;D

first 2 things i got what 2 useless coupons, now i just keep getting coal, just one more to craft it into something!

Congrats!

You want to know how to do all these holidays achievments ? Go here : http://steamtreasurehunt.wikia.com/wiki/Winter_Objectives#19th_December
Don't go if you want to do it by yourself ^^
And this is the list of games that you can win by an achievment or by crafting 7 coals : http://pastebin.com/kDXjjDha
And I got Blood Bowl Legendary Edition (somebody want it ?), Counter Strkie Source (:P) and Fate of the World and some coals and coupons :D

I've completed 11 objectives so far and got Farming Simulator 2011 (traded for Terraria) and Left 4 Dead GOTY. The rest were useless coupons and coals

Just got Dirt 3 from the 'make a recommendation' achievement. I already have that game from way back though XD.

I have crafted 7 Coal, 3 times.
The 1st time i got Valve Complete Pack and used it, 1nd time i got a coupon and 3rd i got ANOTHER Valve Complete pack and traded it for Bulletstorm, Farcry 2 and Borderlands GOTY using Steamtrades so thank you :D

A very good guide. Good job :D

22 objectives complete. Results? Braid, lots of useless coupons and a small stack of coal.

Crafted 7 coal, got another coupon. I have 7 coal in my inventory right now, I'm afraid to use it.

Lucky...

22 objectives done.

GAMES: Counter-Strike Source (already have), Altitude :::
COUPONS: 33% valve, 60% king arthur franchise, 50% bit trip beat, 50% roboblitz, 50% stalker clear sky :::
COAL: 5 (crafted 7 coal into the bit trip beat coupon and I gave away some coal for my brother who crafted a max payne 2 50% coupon.)

I've gotten so far:
Several pieces of coal (given away to Friends)
CS:S (Already had it so I traded it with a friend to get L4D GOTY)
Eufloria
L4D2
Several coupons (Also given away to friends)

Fiinaally, after crafting three times, I got Fallout New Vegas :)