What is your most successful Discussion created?

Well, my most successful thread had 21 comment... Should I mention that I had only 1 thread yet?

I can't honestly remember. Something about calling everyone HERETICS I suspect.

My most successful thread involved me being an idiot and giving away stuff

Mine mostly included people not agreeing over the most obvious and logical puzzle answer.

Here it is: http://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/5wi09/quick-puzzle-with-epic-giveaway-giveaway-is-over

This one and I'm quite proud that it's still active.

I was the bearer of terrible news.
:(

Ah yes, I too had terrible news to impart!

There you go!

i asked people what preorder games they liked and i'd like to think that isaac rebirth won by a landslide :)

Bad news= more comments

This one

The one in which I stopped pretending I'm normal.

i will let my threads die because they are all bad xP

World Cup Thread, 1,137 comments. Fun times ^__^

I don't make many threads, I just like commenting on open ones. That said, the ones that seem to get the most replies are the complainers or mock complainers. "This place is fake!" or "Does this site really give free game?" and stuff like that.

So how many users actually browse the forums?

1911 comments. I never let my Amazon threads grow that big :D

I believe I win.

Mine was 111 comments, from when the Flatout Complete Pack was on sale for $3.03 on Nuuvem.

Almost certainly one of my giveaway threads. :P

Mine was my first giveaway train I did. It got 169 comments.
http://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/KglLp/giveaway-train

I bellieve this one was by far my most popular and heated topic.

A trip down memory lane. :)

postings dont mean its the most "successful" disccusion - most people this days post alot but say nothing - so: facebook generation and dont call this disccussion

have a nice day

SG loves anime.

I'm still using this topic to choose my next anime.