Creators of "first GA of a game"?

Elitism?

Now I've reread it a few times I get the idea and very curious to see what people you will get for it

wow, it's something very interesting! =)
I take part only in three groups on Steam (one of them is Elite One Giveaways, the other two are not-giveaway related even though we make lots of giveaways too, it's not their first purpose), but the idea is quite nice!
In fact, when making some weird giveaway (and it happens from time to time =P), I go to the steamgifts archives to see if someone had already made a giveaway of that particular game and it turned out so far that I made at least 10 "first giveaways" of non-bundled games of course =)
even if I won't apply for any group, I think it's still something very original! it's great to see you're the first one to make a giveaway of a particular game =P (I just have always limited my searches to the steamgifts archive page, though! id est, https://www.steamgifts.com/archive )

In my opinion it would be a group only for rich people :P

€100

Too easy?

If you would consider literally all games ever put on here, you would find an underbelly of SG that many people concerned would like to keep hidden.
Let's just say that one nationality would quite heavily dominate the list.
And that is the better aspect, the not so much good one would be learning one certain infamous key extortionist and his loyal groupies also contributed heavily there, when they were not selling all "promotional" keys on Kinguin.

Can it be found who first gave away a game?

Sounds a bit tedious :D

Also if you are going ahead with this idea I was the first to giveaway SAO Utils, there's quite a few cheap options for unique giveaways.

i like the idea, but, as usual, not the idea of a "group".

maybe a thread like this one, with a list or table or smth... so everybody would know that, say, Oppen first shared xy game, so Oppen is a good guy, so maybe, i will not blacklist him and such... :P

Is this group a good idea?

I was gonna say no, but then I started thinking if there really was a good idea for a group. There really isn't. Make a group if you want to. As long as you have fun and like it, then what's the harm :)

It's a neat idea. If you want it to be a more exclusive group, then make it just high profile games. So either high profile Indie games or any AAA games.
If you want it to be less exclusive, then I don't really know.

I like your idea, and have some comments:

Oldest GA according to Archive, only counting those that reached at least 50+(?) people (entries)

That's penalizing people from posting the first ever GA to a decent small or even medium size group, where average votes per GA are <50. Take a look at groups that average <50 votes per GA and ask yourself "Am I ok with excluding generous gifters from this group?"

Don't count "shit" games. How to define an asset flip or otherwise shit game?

This could easily be done by requiring a certain minimum value, but at the trade off of increasing the group's eliteism. Another option if you want to avoid first ever GA games that are possibly made to be bundle trash, you could require that the game's first GA was not given Reduced Value on or before the date of Reduced Value. That information is easily verifiable with SG's own view GA and create GA pages, respectively.

Pro and con, another small elite group on SG.

Probably, but it could be bigger than you think since there's 10K+ games not including DLCs, and I bet thousands of them have been given away. So it wouldn't surprise me if you could get at least 50-100 people to join after a couple of months of promotion.

"Hey, I think I almost made the first GA of a game" is what I thought when I read your title..
so I went to check and, guess what, according to the Archive I was the first to give it away! :D
and guess what more? You were the winner XD

Just another group with unique special requirements isn't a bad idea and pretty sure some people will like it as some kind of bragging rights even if there's really no other point to the group :P

I'd say make it, not like it matters much apart from the other thousands of groups out there. Nothing wrong with an extra bit of fun right?

Don't count "shit" games.

I'm out of option, most of my GA is game ppl call shit game

Is this group a good idea?

it would be far better than the ~5 new groups announced every day on sg that only exist to feed the person creating them. 🤷

Exclusive 1st Gift, Exclusive 1st Winner, Exclusive Group, Extra, extra, extra! Cameras, Lights, Action!
Can't think of negatives for the group imo, will be interesting to see this group grow. :)

View attached image.

it was almost too easy.