ImPortant Matters II (group/private contribution feelings)

Does it help figuring out who is a bad person?
How does one distinguish someone who found an easier path to farm/raise chances, and users who dont feel like giving games to random people but rather someone who can offer any kind of interactivity.

That would differ from person to person, maybe 70%+
Though to me, it would be a ratio between how much you took from public and how much you gave

Well, if one makes LVL8+ restricted giveaways, one is giving to a small group of close "friend" chances are most of this people are people you see around the forum. Not only do you have an idea who they are you also expect some kind of response not only from the winner but the participants.
One won't get that pleasure making public low level giveaways

Im just curious. i thought users might think you need to contribute in games to be a part of the community
Personally, people shouldnt be obligated to give anything away.
I don't feel i should be worried. I do contribute a lot to groups but i dont try to take more from public than i can give

Thats pretty much what i try to go for, though i don't impose that rule on others.

everyone is entitled to have their own opinion on who should be able to win their giveaways, wouldn't you agree?

Certainly. Though hoarding is an all different matter.
Because...again, not everything is black n white, someone might have a bad looking Group to Public ratio but actually have given more than they won.
Then there are people who dont create giveaways but haven't won that many games, which almost ensures whatever they won would probably be played.
You also have region restricted giveaways, in which the community seems to be torn