I set all my giveaways up to level 3 now, but I feel I keep continually getting winners and those who enter in general turning out to be bots or those with extremely poor CV rates (Yes, sometimes I painstakingly look through the list of entrants). I want to save really good games for group/whitelist giveaways in the future, and I don't want to bother groups or whitelist folk with what most would consider common or cheap things. I also don't think it would necessarily be appropriate to make a train or puzzle for these kinds of games. I don't mind too much that these kinds of games probably won't see the most love, but I'm frustrated when I have to keep chasing people down even though it shows them "online" for days or sometimes a week before they get around to doing anything without even saying thanks. I'm considering raising to level 4, but I still see a lot of the same people at that level too. What's probably the best course of action for this? I've been on here almost 3 months and have been picking up advice here and there already.

1 month ago

Comment has been collapsed.

What should I do about this?

View Results
Just raise the level
Keep the level the same and deal with it
Make invite-only giveways
Something else

I grumbled the same way a month ago because i hoped it all done quickly so i could get on with more difficult things irl. Some nice people gave me some interesting answers about it, especially that it's a question of perception of what's important, and that for many of those who try their luck here i had forgotten that deep down it's not really important.

It's not that people are generous or not, i think they're not all in one piece, it's more that depending on the moment we try different things more or less selfish or generous in a circumstantial way. We all have our specific difficulties more or less, and no one knows what's really going on in the real lives of the people. So... just try your best in a circumstantial way, experiment to determine what makes you most comfortable, and if someone is slow, maybe it's not easy irl for him actually, or maybe he is just slow then reroll and it's his loss. And anyway, who knows in a few years if it'll all still be there.

1 month ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Depends, what is the biggest issue for you.

If it's CV rates, then I would suggest keeping level 3 (or even lowering it to lvl 2) and use SGTools to set the CV ratio thresholds for your GAs, simply posting SGTools links in Don't like bots? Post your random invite-only giveaways here. It's easy to create, and also easy to check, if those entering the GAs have got the GA links in a legitimate way.

If it's mostly the hassle of having to chase the winners, I would suggest joining one of low quaility GA groups, like LootBoy SG. Keeping level 3 threshold should be enough there, and the added benefit is, that it's OK to post somewhat dubious keys there.

If there are good games, that you really want to be played, use one of the most restrictive groups like Playing Appreciated or Playing Matters.

None of those solutions is 100% foolproof, but the mix of them (+ my WL and groups I have chosen) works quite satisfying for me.

And generally, just do, what feels good for you :) As long, as you don't create some 10 people game exchanging ring to cheaply rise your levels (though unfortunately there are some other ways to do so), those are your GAs and you have a full right to decide, what are your requirements for the participants ;)

I've missed, that it's not the second answer, but the 2nd answer on the 2nd page, so a lot of those things have been said before, but I still think, that it's a good summary of the easy options to use.

1 month ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I wouldn't be too worried, to be honest. If it's a pretty great game, you can set the level higher, or give it away to your whitelist or a group. But even then, you can't guarantee that the winner isn't just using it as a +1 for cards. There are a couple of friends on Steam that I see idling their games all the flippin' time and every second game I happen to check the store page of... is on their wishlists. I like them as people, so I overlook it. It's not something you have any control over and it's not that important to me. At the end of the day, I give games away, mostly from bundles, that I will never play, or that I already own, so it's not a loss to me. =)

I would be more annoyed if I paid full price for a game and it was won by someone who had no intention of ever playing.

1 month ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I understand that you would like to continue to make public giveaways (but with less hassle) and that's a good thing. I wouldn't raise the level - but maybe try shortening the time span of your giveaways to 12 hours instead of 24. You can alternate between western and eastern hemispheres if you don't want to leave people on the other side of the planet out. I don't know why, but this seems to cut down on the amount of chasing down winners for me. I wouldn't worry about CV and ratios too much - you never know if it's the person who actually ends up playing the game is the one with the bad ratio.

1 month ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I believe it would create the opposite of the desired effect. Very short giveaways benefit people using autojoiners and bots since people that are not using those mechanisms can't always be around to enter said GAs.

1 month ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I would think so too, and yet it seems to work out to less problems. No idea why. I probably should have mentioned that my public giveaways are level 3, same as OPs.

1 month ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hi there, shortyginger! If you check out older pools about best level for GAs to get rid of bots and similars you'll probably find most people consider level 4 to be the divisional level. So if you want to be double sure you can even create GAs to lvl 5.
With that said if you want to be sure that only people that you deem (trust)worthy can enter some great giveaways that you create, the best course is to add a bunch of said people in your whitelist and then create the giveaways for WL only.

1 month ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I create level 4 giveaways and it's fine for me.

1 month ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Make all gibs level 11 or blacklist some people you will not find the perfect winner EVEN NICE PEOPLE HERE ON SG DON'T ALWAYS PLAY THEIR WINS

Often creating a whitelist will make it too restrictive, groups will still have leechers, and raising the level won't weed out many bad people.
Better yet, create a new group, and advertise it and then do special group-only giveaways. You will still be disappointed, but then you will only have yourself to blame ;)

1 month ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Check out the group "Playing Appreciated". Sounds like exactly what you are looking for.

1 month ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Level 3 is just the best, so stay up there.

1 month ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I don't worry too much about what people do with their wins...it only leads to stressing out the giver, so I figure you've already built up good karma -- why worry about their bad karma? ;)

The only thing I don't like is chasing down winners who don't activate (and I re-roll at 7 days), which I will do because I hate incomplete lists. :D
This is another reason I create events...I mean, it's mostly because it gives me a creative outlet and I like doing fun things for people, but it has the side benefit of focusing the pool of entrants to larger percentage of people who are paying attention and will activate their wins.

1 month ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Closed 1 month ago by shortyginger.