Well what is your first indie game played for first time?

minecraft

I think it was some shareware title during the early 90's. Can't remember which one though, as I played quite a few.

VVVVVV

Flower probably.

Meincampf!

Bastion

Gish probably. I don't know any other indies before it. There probably were other but I don't remember ...

Old indie games that you could download for free.. I can't remember the name.

From the new wave is probably Minecraft

I believe it was LIMBO.

Doukutsu Monogatari (Download free version of Cave Story)

Prince of Persia.

Isaac, a guy was from a forum was kind enough to give it to me for free ^^. One of the greatest indies tbh.

I played isaac not really like it :(

Doujin games count? If that's the case, Hydra Castle Labyrinth: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EoUXJBFmdvw

Bastion.

Super Hexagon

Audiosurf!

Cave story(the free version)

Verdun, my first game purchase

What about Magicka or the show down effect :D that was my first steam buy!

Worms ♥

Braid <3

Not counting widely available shareware games from the 90's, I'd say the Exile (the origin of the Avernum remakes) demos from Spiderweb was one of the first games I remember finding when I first got internet.

Hacker Evolution

Likely some freeware/shareware game I downloaded off a BBS in ye olden days.