Great games I need on my Wishlist?

I've seen tons of threads already about "What games I should buy" (felt like feeding the flames) and this thread did not help me at all.

Would appreciate if you'd give me ideas, currently playing Fallout 1 and will play Fallout 2 right after I finish: wishlist & all games

Games I found boring/don't really want them:

• Saints Row 3 (have it on Ps3, did not like)
• Grand Theft Auto
• Just Cause 2 (have on Ps3, it's decent)
• Killing Floor
• The Elder Scrolls Oblivion + Skyrim
• Dungeons of Dredmor
• Thief
• The Last Remnant
• Gemini Rue
• Divine Divinity
• Deus Ex
• Castle Crashers
• Depths of Peril
• Torchlight
• Super Meatboy
• Bastion
• Dishonored (have it on Ps3, someone told me not to bother playing it)
• Eschalon I + II
• Geneforge (1-5)
• Bioshock 1 (haven't tried 2)
• Witcher 1 (haven't tried 2)
• Half Life 2 (haven't tried 1)
• Dear Esther

Games I've enjoyed:

• Fallout New Vegas (Fallout series in general)
• YS Series
• Braid
• Metro 2033
• Hack Slash & Loot
• KOTOR I (haven't played II)
• The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
• Terraria (yes I know about Starbound)
• FTL
• Lost Planet (have both #1 + #2 on my Ps3)
• Borderlands 1 + 2 (have both on Ps3, do not intend to buy for Steam)
• Penumbra
• Carpe Fulgur Games
• To the Moon