Alan Wake, Yay or Nay?

I'm not sure what you mean with "yay or nay", but if you are asking if it's a good game, believe me, it's awesome ^^

Yahy. Good game.

Totally YAY, I loved this game, latest chapters are not as great as first ones, but ninotheless - it's fresh and very well executed new look at survive-horror genre. I LOVED IT :3

Thanks for the feedback of the game, seems like I'm going to buy it then :=)