Anime recommendations?

Haikyuu!!
Magi
Nanatsu no Taizai
Mushishi
xxxHOLiC
Gungrave
Beck
Gankutsuou
Akatsuki no Yona

great ones with ~ 26ep:

• Tentai Senshi Sunred
• Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
• Usagi Drop
• NHK ni Youkoso!
• One Outs
• Gankutsuou
• Samurai Champloo
  ..

Berserk! The anime is short, like you wanted, but the manga is still going on.

Already on your to watch list, but Psycho Pass is really good. Season 2 (only 12 eps) is really good (but you have to watch season 1 first).

Parasyte
GATE
BTOOOM
Another
Hellsing
Claymore
Mirai Nikki
Death Note
Black lagoon

AKIRA
BERSERK [movies] skip the series]
MindGame [movie]

''lesser anime's'' but still enjoyable for me it was at least*

Darker than Black
Chaos Head
Gantz

My top recommendations are Ghost in the Shell (all of it, but the first, second, and SAC movies are the best, though the SAC series are required to know everything going on in the movie, and there are slight spoilers if you skip the series), Time of Eve (provoking "art house" short series about androids; not particularly exciting but cool animation and interesting style), Trigun (a classic, it's just great), Jin Roh (another classic), and Ergo Proxy (a bit of mind-screw with your action), with Working (dysfunctional family restaurant comedy) and Acchi Kocchi (slice of life meets romantic comedy where everything is okay and happy) to lighten the mood.

No game no life

Darker Than Black 1, Toradora!, No Game No Life, Angel Beats! and Amagi Brilliant Park. All masterpieces! :3

Anything I rated 9-10

I found these pastebins a friend sent me years ago. I haven't watched them all, but these are his recommendations, with short descriptions and content warnings (I was, at one point, fairly sheltered. I also had a mirror behind my monitor, so everyone could see what I was watching.):
http://pastebin.com/raw.php?i=W2pKAyB2
http://pastebin.com/raw.php?i=DcWYjRpt

From the list, I realized I completely forgot Sora no Woto, which is the happiest apocalypse ever.

I would strike Kotura-san from the list, since the show was weak throughout (started strong, went downhill) and some of the shows (like Working!, which now has three seasons) are out of date.

Where are the mecha?
First GAINAX jewels: Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann | FLCL | Top Wo Nerae! Gunbuster Diebuster
Mobile Suit Gundam
Eureka Seven (50 ep, but worth it)
Sidonia no Kishi
Bt'x
Ghost in the Shell
Aldnoah.Zero
Kurogane no Linebarrels

Shokugeki no Souma, Card Captor Sakura, Keroro Gunsou, No Game No Life, 7 deadly sins.

ELFEN LIED!

Don't hold it, go watch it now, I ate through it on a weekend and it was amazing

Gakkou Garashi, the best anime for anime casuals who are searching for a Slice of Life anime...
Yep nothing strange or unsettling at all hahaha...
Overlord
Charlotte
Denpa Kyoshi
Erm... Himouto Umaru
Er... Dragon Ball Super?
GATE
Steins ; Gate
Barakamon
Akame Ga Kill
I can't think of too many out of my head right now but I'll keep these here for now.

Chobits is one i finally got around to watching it's a little ecchi but not really that over the top like a lot of stuff i've watched

Akame ga Kill! is on your to watch list so JUST DO IT

Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann is one of my favorite animes i've watched maybe 200 serise and this is one of the best going the first 2-3 episodes may seem a little slow but stick with it well worth a watch.

Sc-Ry-D is pretty old but damn it was well worth a watch when i got around to it.

I have to add this one Yuru Yuri girls doing girly things and it's oh so funny and they are making another season of it so hyper for the moe cuteness and the damn fine hair.

Boku no Pico

I'm at work right now so I'll just mention the ones I remember right now (I might update this list later)

• Kaiji
• Kara no Kyoukai
• Record of Lodoss War
• Ore Monogatari (it ends in 2 days)
• Haibane Renmei
• Kino's Journey
• Prison School
• Here is Greenwood
• Fate/Zero
• Shinsekai Yori
• Attack on Titan
• Haikyuu
• Kuroko's Basketball
• Princess Tutu
• Nodame Cantabile
• Seitokai Yakuindomo
• Hi no Tori

I will just mention one, Spice & Wolf. Trust me on this one, you won't regret it :3

Too lazy to type another list, so I'll link to my previous posts:
This
And this

Berserk

This

Also, the OVA movies aren't too bad. Three out sofar?

And you already have Trigun there. Really great imo.

The Third: Aoi Hitomi no Shōjo is really good. Full Metal Panic is really good if you like comedies.

JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (Phantom blood, Battle tendency, Stardust crusaders), Shimoneta, Himouto, Onepunch man