Max Payne 3 Vs Far Cry 3

they are both different, made to appeal different audieces, max payne 3 is made to appeal those who love good stories, awesome cinematics, noir stuff, TPS and slow-mo. far cry 3 is made to appeal to fps fast pace fans, with open world, roleplaying to the extreme etc.
but unfortunely, even as a max payne fan, i think farcry 3 wins the award

Not sure... I really like the story and the setting behind Max Payne 3.