how do i start? yes my topic title is very provocative!

i started with MP1 since it was first announced with all the previous game art (different enemies on motorcycles etc.) and pushed back all the way. then it came out and it still blows me away, i just love the style, the lone cop, the comic strips, the whole gameplay! AWESOME!
i also love the realistic artstyle and scanned graphics.

MP2 was for me a letdown, as far as i remember (i only played it once, unlike MP1 which i played multiple times!) the story was very bland for me and i didnt like the whole progression, still gameplaywise it was great.

MP3 i play it some hours now and it just pisses me off!
the shooting mechanics are maybe the best in the series, i really love the details etc. but:

  • i dont like the overusage of those fucking effects in the cutscenes
  • i hate the cutscenes! they are too often and too long
  • Max talks too much, i dont remember talking this much!
  • every 2-3 minutes after 1 enemy encounter the next cutscene follows, blablablabla
  • the graphics are nice but it looks not the realistic artstyle way but GTA/comically.... i dont like it

the score however is really tight so far! i love it. again i also love the shooting, when you dont fucking watch another cutscene..... yeah i accepted (but hate the decision) that they removed the comic strips.

i know that opinions get bashed nowadays against AAA games but i wanted to let it out!

EDIT
im nearly though it now, shows how annoying and boring it is when i left off a game and play later on!
more points which suck so hard

  • when you die you always have to watch a small sequence again
  • many unfair situations where 4 guys already surround u and shoot immediately, lazy balancing
  • max payne really should have stfu, every 1 he talks about shit, and 1000 times how he failed and shown how he drinks alcohol. yeah i get it....
  • the story is very underwhelming and not max paynish.... the setting had some nice touches with the flashbacks, sorry max in brazil doesnt fit

this game PISSES ME SO OFF! i thought it would get better but to watch 5-10 minutes cutscenes between chapters and the level structure like this:
walk -> cutscene -> shoot 2-5 guys -> cutscene -> shoot 3 guys -> cutscene -> walk -> railshooterscene -> cutscene -> walk -> cutscene -> shoot 8 guys -> long cutscene and so on.

wtf?! i already had no fun and wanted to quit after chapter 7 but i dotnt like unfinished games and i didnt want to accept that it gets worse and a beloved series's fell to shit!

thanks rockstar and remedy for fucking up MP3, all those praising reviews are just garbage and were on a hype train or dunno what max payne was about!

too bad, some moments were nice (especially the new york onesI) and the soundtrack is great!

SPOILER summary of MP3 and its gameplay
Chapter 1 - end
walk -> cutscene -> shoot 2-5 guys -> cutscene -> shoot 3 guys -> cutscene -> walk -> railshooterscene -> cutscene -> walk -> cutscene -> shoot 8 guys -> long cutscene and so on.

7 years ago*

Comment has been collapsed.

Nobody cares

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

that's exactlly what the gaming community came to nowadays, consisting of people like you.

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Optimization was very good and thats it.

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I really enjoyed these things in max payne 3 to be honest , too bad you don't fully enjoy it , but the story is really good and worth watching ... believe me , it might not be the best in the series but it's damn good.

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sometimes the best is just the first one game, cuz when the video games have a second shot could be really disappointing for us js. Im really sorry about that btw :(

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

View attached image.
7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

For an opposing opinion, I found the first two to be abysmal- buggy, clunky, shallow, repetitive, and all-around unpleasant to play- while the current one is, from what I've seen, far more accessible, polished, immersive, and engaging.

Likewise, I disliked the original Tomb Raider games for similar reasons, while the remake series is an even bigger step forward from its predecessors than Max Payne 3 is from its own.

Inevitably- unless we're talking franchises like Assassin's Creed- styles will eventually change. Much like with how a majority seem to view Dark Souls 2 as the worst in the series, while a minority claim the opposite, stylistic changes often end up being more a difference in who they appeal to, than of overall improvements or declines. Which isn't to say that some games aren't just failures under more objective considerations [like, say, Lara Croft: Temple of Osiris, which is buggy to the point of unplayability], but that generally, what you're venting about is dissimilarity, rather than negativity.

This, of course, is why it's always important to carefully review games before purchasing :glances at the URL bar: or otherwise acquiring them. Compared to a few decades ago, information on games is readily accessible and often deeply in-depth. Sometimes there's no avoiding getting a disappointing game- some things can't really be (dis)appreciated unless encountered first-hand, but it's usually a great way to determine things like, say, if a game has introduced lengthy cutscenes into its franchise. ~.^

(P.S. All the things you mentioned sound great to me, and are elements that contribute to the improvements on the things I found weak in the original games. It is what it is~)

7 years ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

(Though I'll agree that not having control over skipping cutscenes is always a bad design element.)

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Story is mostly acceptable. There is one chapter that reminds me good old max payne - and I loved it (but I don't know how much you have played so no spoilers).
Shooting - yea, probably best in whole series.

What I hated in this game was "shooter on rails" parts. Just who thought that it was good idea to put them there?

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

chapter 4? really enjoyed it! but i dont like that he has a sidekick.

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

yup! night and snow... felt like in noir york city again...
that sidekick though xD

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

At least you can't skip most of the cutscenes, because reasons!

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

so the moral of the story is you don't like the cutscenes cause they happen too often.

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

no giveaway boys, get out.

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

in chapter 5 now. man so much self pitiful talk, i never thought this would annoy me so much. still he talks every shit, they overdone mp character this way, also i miss the small details like the bumps the tvs etc. the game is heavily linear too, mp was never complex but not this linear.

worst title in the series for sure. too bad, i really love the score so far but as expected this is just not feeling like a badass mp game.

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

It's a demo for GTA V. :p Yeah i really didn't like it either.

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

im nearly though it now, shows how annoying and boring it is when i left off a game and play later on!
more points which suck so hard

  • when you die you always have to watch a small sequence again
  • many unfair situations where 4 guys already surround u and shoot immediately, lazy balancing
  • max payne really should have stfu, every 1 he talks about shit, and 1000 times how he failed and shown how he drinks alcohol. yeah i get it....
  • the story is very underwhelming and not max paynish.... the setting had some nice touches with the flashbacks, sorry max in brazil doesnt fit

this game PISSES ME SO OFF! i thought it would get better but to watch 5-10 minutes cutscenes between chapters and the level structure like this:
walk -> cutscene -> shoot 2-5 guys -> cutscene -> shoot 3 guys -> cutscene -> walk -> railshooterscene -> cutscene -> walk -> cutscene -> shoot 8 guys -> long cutscene and so on.

wtf?! i already had no fun and wanted to quit after chapter 7 but i dotnt like unfinished games and i didnt want to accept that it gets worse and a beloved series's fell to shit!

thanks rockstar and remedy for fucking up MP3, all those praising reviews are just garbage and were on a hype train or dunno what max payne was about!

too bad, some moments were nice (especially the new york onesI) and the soundtrack is great!

SPOILER summary of MP3 and its gameplay
Chapter 1 - end
walk -> cutscene -> shoot 2-5 guys -> cutscene -> shoot 3 guys -> cutscene -> walk -> railshooterscene -> cutscene -> walk -> cutscene -> shoot 8 guys -> long cutscene and so on.

7 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sign in through Steam to add a comment.