[ here was a semi-random story about why I need mindreaders] It was irrelevant, as I said.
FIND OUT HERE: http://www.itstoohard.com/puzzle/WpE1mpgF

Solution

It's kind of a puzzler 101. Look for unnecessary capital letters, bold letters, TEXT IN ITALICS or page source.
If you were paying attention you noticed that the giveaway ends at "11:58 pm". That's a little weird, isn't it? Especially when in italics - It was a direct reference to Iron Maiden's 2 Minutes to Midnight
First hits for " 11.58 pm music" in google:
-Klaymore - 11:58 PM (Iron Maiden Homage)
-"11:58 pm only metalheads get it" FB post with lots of Iron Maiden releated comments.

+1: the hint also had Iron Maiden songs' titles in italics - Moonchild, Sanctuary, and the wonderful Wasted Years. All three from Maiden, all three in italics - so it served as a double-hint (pay attention to italics, and Maiden)
Hope at least with this explanation I can help you to make the terrifying puzzles a little more friendly - if you know basics like this, they are much enjoyable, most puzzles turn into detective work from unsolvable cryptics :)