These days? "Racism" is something people try to use for political gain, whereas "Reality" is something people try to avoid.
Comment has been collapsed.
So, developers should put only white people in videogames, because that's how the world should look like? I think you're a racist, not the developers who's makes games alike the reality. Also, you're a moron. Oh, and filmakers should not make WW2 movies, because that's fascist. And should not make movies what's shows the world before the ~80s, because in the '50s-'60s, the blacks were not equal with whites in the US. The linked picture is also from that era...
Comment has been collapsed.
I think you missed the part where he was being sarcastic...
Comment has been collapsed.
racism is ok I don't see pansy elves being equal to others I say let them only have elf stuff!
Comment has been collapsed.
Is that image offensive? yes. Are people racist for buying The Stanley Parable? No.
People did not buy The Stanley Parable because of the racist image. That's like saying if you wear Nike's then you are okay with slave labor. Or everyone who owns an iPhone likes sweatshops. One isn't mutually exclusive to the other. However, I think the fact that the developer is planning on patching the game to remove the offensive imagery speaks volumes that they are concerned enough to not pull a Phil Fish and say "f-you I don't care what you don't like about my game."
Comment has been collapsed.
It does speak volumes of how much of a piss ant coward the dev's are. And Phil Fish was in the right, you don't like images, sounds, or whatever in a game, don't play it, that simple. No need to go off and bytch'n'moan about it to others.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes but won't the dev of the said "unplayed" game have a mental breakdown then? Double edged sword!
Comment has been collapsed.
Why is that image offensive? It's just a man who's setting a kid on fire... If you're not racist, don't look at his skin colour...
Comment has been collapsed.
I find a man setting children on fire a bit offensive. Didn't even consider the kid's race.
Comment has been collapsed.
Its a strange image, and it might bother some people who believe that violent images make violent people. But you're right, its not racist.
Comment has been collapsed.
Can someone explain to me how playing Borderlands 2 makes me racist? I genuinely want to know. Thanks.
Comment has been collapsed.
Because only certain races can talk certain ways. That is so much more offensive to say. Jesus Christ I hate people.
Comment has been collapsed.
What abaris919 said + i would like to add that words used by Tiny Tinas like "oh snap" and "crumpets are crunk" are almost exclusive to afroamerican community and their use by anyone else would define them as a mockery. It is too late now to ask for a refund for emotional damage this might have caused but if you didnt get to that part yet, i would advise you to do what i did: turn the volume all the way down when you get to the missions with Tiny Tina (and subtitles as well) so you won't be negatively affected by her choice of words. After you're done with her sidequests, turn the volume back up, enable the subtitles and you should have your feeling intact. Best of luck!
Comment has been collapsed.
SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Anyone ACTUALLY offended by Tiny Tina has issues, imho.
When I first played the Tina Tina quests, there had not been any debate on her, yet, and it seemed like "crazy-cool" to me. She's like 12, lost both her parents (IIRC), is the best expert on detonating stuff on the entire planet, permanently ADD'ing AND speaking "ghetto". It's just the package that makes Tiny Tina.
NOWHERE in the game there are racist behaviours that need to be made public.
It rather .. astonishes me that you didn't mention Roland being a (black) leader. Pretty much the chief there.
I know, I know...he does die. But .. have you played TTADK ? they do make a statement on all those things. Quite strong statements, in fact..
I don't know where I'm going with this..
It's just there are way more important things to deal with on this planet.. than some freaking chick in a videogame.
Comment has been collapsed.
True. But heck SPOILER alert there! Edit the damn post! :/
Comment has been collapsed.
Well.. searching the internet now to understand what "Ghetto Talk" means, and taking into account that I've already did the Tiny Tina's side quests are facts that i didnt get the references nor i have been offened by it personally.
Generally, a lot of movies, tv series and games contain stigmas, politics, and such things. As most of them might already influenced you, I hope you, as much as I am, are old enough to not let those things affect us negatively.
In other words, try to enjoy the game presented to you by taking it as a mere cartoon'ish science fiction. Dont try to search references to real life. Personlly I liked Tiny Tina very much. She is a cute cartoon'ish character for me. Nothing more, nothing less.
I hope others will do the same, and not get offeneded by a mere video game.
As an Israeli guy, I am well aware how far racism can go.
Cheers.
Comment has been collapsed.
isn't it strange? "it" being today's society.
I have German ancestors, you have Israeli ancestors - fuck there's been a LOT of damage done.
But nontheless, we both have the same opinion on a 12 year old talking "ghetto" in a video game.
It just amazes me.. history compared to today's standards.
Please don't be offended - I hope I wrote all that right.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm not offened at all. In fact I have several german friends on steam (even an Iranian friend) whom I talk to without any grudges or whatnot.
I find it amazing that our society can leave past things behind. Much credit to the internet ofcourse.
Comment has been collapsed.
Oh, I remember I wached it. Thanks for sharing :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Aren't you overeacting at little bit (or are you being ironic? my sarcasm detectors are off right now)? I haven't played the game but Boarderlands is set in a futuristic (and fictional) setting so making such direct comparisons seems a little excessive to me. Even in our society things that were at some point almost exclusively, and often negatively, associated with one group can over time lose this exclusivity and even these associations. For example jazz and rap. You wouldn't call a white musician racist/racially offensive just because he performs these genres, would you?
Comment has been collapsed.
if letting white children burn is okey but black not, THATS RACISM!
that image made uncomfortable but for totally different reason. why in the first place is he lighting cigar for that kid?! are we now promoting smoking to young children? if there is some "you have to play it to understand" then sorry but I didnt play it yet. still its very weird. @OP: I see no racism in it
Comment has been collapsed.
So you're saying that for me not to be a racist I must first have a look at a person's skin colour before evaluating the severity of their actions? That's so... ironic.
And the picture is taken out of context and thus makes no sense.
Comment has been collapsed.
So many people responding without realizing that this is satire.
Comment has been collapsed.
My sarcasm skill is not high enough! Teach me, master!
Seriously though, I'm tired of people seeing racism and sexism EVERYWHERE. It's really damn annoying. And now a dev is being forced to change his game because of that bullshit. Freedom of speech my ass.
But, heck, what the hell could I do? People are apparently programmed to find as many reasons to hate each other as possible. What could us defective types possibly do? :/
Comment has been collapsed.
He's not being forced to change. Read the article. Two people contacted him -- politely -- to say that the image made them feel uncomfortable, including a schoolteacher who said that it made her feel that she couldn't share it with her class. The dev thought about this a bit, then decided that the parts that were bothering them were not important to the joke and, especially, that he wanted his game to be accessible to a lot of people (including something that could be shown to kids in school), so he decided to change it.
What exactly is wrong with that?
That's why the OP had to resort to crude exaggerated satire in order to try and get people whipped up into a frenzy about ZOMG VIDEOGAME MAKER FORCED TO CHANGE BY PC COLLECTIVE HIVEMIND, because the actual story is just people being reasonable and talking to each other like adults and a game designer deciding that something in their game wasn't appropriate for their (entire) intended audience.
Comment has been collapsed.
So, did you read the article then? I mean- the entire article. In the last paragraph the guy who "felt uncomfortable" clearly implies that he found that image as "racist".
Now the question is this: Did the dev REALLY decide to change the image because it didn't deliver the message they wanted... or did they decide on that because they realized that otherwise the game would inevitably sooner or later get framed as "racist" (aka, the Resident Evil 5 and Borderlands 2 "incidents")?
Of course that depends on how you look at it, but think about it for a moment.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm not seeing it. People have the right to complain, for whatever reason; devs have the right to tweak their product in light of complaints, or to ignore them or whatever. If it hurts their sales, hey, that's what happens -- you have to know your audience (and decide who you're selling to, obviously.)
Why did you put scare-quotes around racist and incidents? Some people complained that those games bothered them. So what? Different people are bothered by different things; everyone has things that bother them and things that they find stupid, and it's not some horrific injustice if people disagree on that. It didn't cause the games to disappear and it didn't seem to hurt their sales.
I don't know, it feels to me like you're the one looking for an excuse to get offended here. The article, at least at face value, just seems to be about people being reasonable, and you're trying to frame it in a way that will let you feel that your buttons are being pushed so you can get upset. How are you any different from the people you're talking about?
Comment has been collapsed.
So the image in the Stanley Parable, which out of context seems to itself be commentary on imperialist influences destroying the peoples of indigenous cultures, is some how racist? How about the idea that it's okay to kill white zombies but not black ones simply because of skin color? If a game were set in Russia, and all you killed were black zombies, that would be racist. The game is set in Africa. If you were shooting hordes of white zombies something would seem out of place. I'm glad you're being sarcastic because otherwise I would have to bludgeon myself insane again.
Again.
Comment has been collapsed.
Love the phrasing on the main OP.
Other than that, there isn't much to say, stupidity and intolerance is everywhere (hell i can read some of it right here), and sadly there's no escaping from it no matter where you go.
Comment has been collapsed.
Now some questions from me:
What's wrong with "All hail the German Reich?", it just means I wish all hail to the German Reich, which isn't just the 3rd Reich and has existed for more than one Millenium, you are de facto living in it, it just has changed it's name, so why do people think it's wrong to say this?
And why do especially German people like you think the German Reich just existed from 1933 - 1945 and are so afraid of symbols and words, which were abused in this time?
No wonder the world is laughing over us.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm not sure how to express this... I'm guessing "hail" or rather "Heil" (automatically) brings up the thought .. the image .. of millions "sieg heil'ing" Moustache Man.
which didn't bring good - we're clear on that, are we? :P
It's not that I'm offended when people use these troll mechanisms on German folks.
As I was saying.. I guess it raises the wrong kind of awareness.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yep, no moustache man intended!
Indeed, people may think I'm serious with it, but that's intended when you are writing this stuff.
I just answered because you are a German yourself. :d
So, we both don't like the moustache man and we both understand the history of our country.
All fine I think? ^^ Except the point that I may get a suspension from a raging mod. shrug
Comment has been collapsed.
27 Comments - Last post 14 minutes ago by Gamy7
46 Comments - Last post 15 minutes ago by ZPE
16,406 Comments - Last post 31 minutes ago by Atro
7 Comments - Last post 33 minutes ago by lostsoul67
8 Comments - Last post 37 minutes ago by lostsoul67
10 Comments - Last post 37 minutes ago by pb1
741 Comments - Last post 47 minutes ago by orono
69 Comments - Last post 1 minute ago by silkst
8 Comments - Last post 2 minutes ago by Vincer
482 Comments - Last post 4 minutes ago by WaxWorm
33 Comments - Last post 8 minutes ago by pizzahut
93 Comments - Last post 10 minutes ago by puninup
89 Comments - Last post 13 minutes ago by Mayanaise
453 Comments - Last post 14 minutes ago by Estbarul
Chances are if you ever bought Resident Evil 5 or Borderlands 2, you did. If you thought that killing black people in Africa and using "oh but they're just zombies" is a valid excuse or a white girl using ghetto talk is perfectly fine by your standards (because we all know how that type of communication is reserved for African Americans and no one else)then i would strongly advise you to check your privilege. Someone even made a handy Android app just for that
The latest example in this despicable trend is now Stanley Parable. Look at this ingame picture and tell me that there is nothing wrong with it. Now i imagine you're all probably brimming with rage so let me just explain you why you should be mad and scream for demanding of social justice in the first place. You see, there is nothing wrong that a grown man is setting a kid on fire, the problem here is his skin color (and i'm pretty sure the situation and public outrage would be the same if the roles were reversed, r-right?)
I bet you're all probably asking yourself what can i do at this point except nagging on the internet while trying to make a controversy out of nothing but! - that's where you would be wrong. With enough commitment and a lot of free time there is a chance that DICE might just hire you to work on a Mirror's Edge sequel with insightful unbiased advices or get a job in many of the Gawker media affiliates - the possibilities are almost endless.
So whenever you see a Black, Asian or Australian character in a videogame you should ask yourself why is he/she there in the first place if they don't have a leading role in providing a social commentary, we don't want you to play games just to have fun, that would be crazy!. Next time you see a videogame that you might like, dont just blindly buy it. Do some research, be sure to overanalyze everything and if that process you tend to separate a fiction from the reality, who cares? It's part of the package
tl;dr
If you buy Stanley Parable before they patch it, you are most likely racist
Comment has been collapsed.