. . .

5 days ago

Comment has been collapsed.

Which game is your favorite of the four: Starbound, Terraria, My Time at Portia, or Stardew Valley?

View Results
My Time At Portia
Starbound
Stardew Valley
Terraria

Graveyard Keeper?

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

^_^" ...Gleaner Heights ?

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Man this game was total disappointment. You never felt progressing at anything. You just kept hitting barriers and the game felt like it never picked up any pace. There was so much back and forth movement for just about everything you had to do. It was bland and so boring.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Those "unethical dilemmas" that were advertised in-game weren't really dilemmas. Thou must commit in order to progress.
Graveyard Keeper was a fun game, but the walls for progression went higher and higher. I also felt like some mechanics like alchemy and church sermons weren't explained well or didn't give you enough resources. Church sermons in particular were killer trouble if you missed the one day to do them on, and not to mention that you start off with meagre rewards and will continue to if you don't figure out how to up your production. I'm just glad zombie workers are a thing, even if it means having to pay attention to them now and then. Less back-and-forth this way.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

So many things were not explained well or not explained at all. You were bound to refer to a wiki in order to make most out of the stuff present in the game. And I agree that the requirements for progressing just kept piling up and made the pacing so slow all the time. In the initial hours, I always kept thinking that maybe if I do a few quests then I would have some equipment or tools that would help to speed things up. But I was so wrong. Also agree with the sermons and alchemy... It was all too vague. Same with the embalming. It was all too convoluted and stayed that way.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Played only Starbound and Terraria and I liked Starbound more.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Huh... :D "Starbound Valley" ?

( As I really loves them both, so... )

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Only played Terraria and Stardew Valley, so my answer will be a little skewed :)

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Maybe Terraria or StarBound with friends, Stardew alone

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

No one, only Slime Rancher.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

terraria rules em all

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Terraria just got another major free content update... 9 years after release.
I don't think I need to point out which one of those I think is the best.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I've played through the content for all four of these. If you're playing alone, definitely Stardew; I've logged well over 100 hours in that alone across several playthroughs both by myself and with others. If you plan on playing with friends, Terraria hands down, of the four it provides the most entertainment with a group and has excellent replayability after completion. Starbound is also great, but I found it to be a little more tedious than Terraria and I personally had some connectivity issues when playing with friends (though that could have just been us). Finally, Portia is fun at first, but becomes something of a grind by then end and the story wasn't so engaging. It's still fun for a bit, but I'd recommend that one least of all.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Thank you for the excellent summary. I got more from that than I did from reading all of the other reviews for the games. )

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I honestly can't decide. But I'd say the vote goes to the one that my friends decides to play.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I think it would be more meaningful for the comparison to be done separately in groups of two, Terraria with Starbound and Stardew Valley with My Time At Portia. Probably the last group is harder to compare.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I'm surprised by the result of the poll! Starbound is definitely my favorite.
Starbound vs Terraria - Starbound for me.
Stardew vs My Time At Portia - this one is hard for sure. I'm playing Portia right now. And it's fun. It definitely feels like a copy of Stardew, even music theme in the menu starts off similarly. Stardew is good, but I felt farming was somewhat of a chore. During my 30 hours I haven't managed to get to sprinklers. That's too slow / too long. Portia has some good ideas, but boy, does mining feel weird/clunky, huh?

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sprinklers are quite easy to get. Try not to plant to much, so you have more energy left over for example going to the mine on a rainy day or going fishing.

The best sprinklers take a while, but upgrading the watercan for example is also a good strategy as you can water more plants. But therefor you need to go to the mines :)

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

My two favorites lead the poll, you are good people.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

stardew valley - only one i played

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Factorio

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Played Stardew, Starbound and Terraria. I liked the latter 2 more, and which of those 2 the most? Idk, they both scratched a different itch. Terraria for combat and art style, Starbound for exploring/building.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I've played Terraria and love it, +100 hours invested
Also heard extremely good reviews from Stardew Valley
Starbound is good, I only hate the lack of a map (unless they added that, don't know)
Never played My Time at Portia so can't tell

I would say, for single player, Stardew, for multiplayer, Terraria

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Haven't played My Time At Portia, but of the rest I enjoyed Terraria the most.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

No love for Rimworld? :')

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

beats Rimworld with a stick

Sorry, but I couldn't resist making a joke, there. I've never played Rimworld.
(If only I had the skillz to make a GIF for that joke. Ah, well...)

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I don't played one of them...
but i think the others gave good "reviews" :o)

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Which one draws your attention the most?

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Stardew Valley from the art and Terraria because a few that i know play it and talk about it in a discord.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I'm old, I play the "Harvest Moon" card, or the "Rune Factory" one...

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

RF5 got pushed back, NOOOOOOOOOOOOO

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Well, almost every game is or will be delayed... What an ugly time period this is...

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Terraria.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

stardew valley is really lacking in content, unless you go for mods

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I'll call bs on this claim, with my ~300 hours in SV. And that was some years ago, with tons of content added meanwhile.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hey, people are free to their opinions. I think the fact he has spent over 50hrs in the game and has a good chunk of the achievements gives at least some validity to his statement. I for one got sick of the game after 5hrs, but only because it's a farming simulator, and not because it's necessarily a bad game.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Almost all of the achievements within 2 days. There's no way you can get 75% of achievements in only 2 days in a legit way. 1M gold in his first day playing the game? (I have a few hours and I don't even have the 15K gold achievement) He cheated very hard and then complains not enough content.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Not sure why you are accusing someone of cheating, that was uncalled for.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

To be fair, you brought up their achievements to give their opinion credibility. If those achievements also lack credibility though, it absolutely makes sense to mention it in this context.
Not that it would really matter imho. The game has enough content, otherwise it wouldn't have such a reputation.And if Vahid thinks differently for whatever reason, that's up to him.We are still allowed to disagree though.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

No, I bring up the point that if the achievements lacked credibility, he could have just used ASF or whatever that program is, and unlocked all of them. Get my drift?

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

That's a futile discussion which won't lead us anywhere. Just because someone doesn't unlock all achievements, doesn't mean that those achievements they got are all legit.
But as I already wrote, imho it doesn't matter anyway.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

If it didn't matter, you wouldn't have commented. I was trying to have a civil discussion, but throwing in rude comments like "it doesn't matter", and then replying again just goes to show that it does matter.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I didn't bring up achievements. And I was trying to have a civil discussion as well, that's why I offered some context in the dialogue you two had.
I have no idea how "it doesn't really matter" is rude. All I try to communicate by that is that achievements aren't relevant in giving too simply expressed opinions more or less weight. So yes, achievements don't matter. If that is rude, so be it. I'm out.

5 days ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I didn't deny them their opinion, I just evaluated their claim using my own right to express my opinion too.
And seriously, at the very least it is a too simplistic claim. If they had said something like "Stardew Valley offers less to explore than Terraria", that would have been fine. Those two games don't compete in that regard.
The way it was expressed though I don't have any other option than to consider it questionable. Aka bs. ;)

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Well, I for one am not gonna argue the finer points of the game and whether it's lacking content, as I said I only put about 6hrs into the game - enough for me to personally accept the game as not for me, but clearly not enough to have an opinion on whether the game is shit or not.

Calling someone else's opinion bs a bit rich though - Vahid revisited the game a couple years after first playing it, so it's not like he had a shot and gave up on the game in one go.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I like both Stardew and Portia. Haven't played the other 2

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I've played them all.

  1. Stardew Valley
  2. Terraria
  3. Starbound
  4. My Time At Portia
5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I'd like to try My Time at Portia, as I prefer 3D worlds rather than 2D pixel graphics, though I'm not sure these games are really my thing.
I tried Stardew Valley, but after 5hrs all I could see just a grindy farm sim with a limited, not very enjoyable rpg-maker style gameplay.

5 days ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sign in through Steam to add a comment.