This giveaway looks fishy.

I say you're paranoid.

Why the PopCap pack, though?
It does seem suspicious, but we can't be sure. I wouldn't like to treat him like a fake giveaway maker since he might also be a generous person.

Aww man, this one too... I didn't look that closely before, but now that I had a look at his Steam profile, which contains only 7 games, which had to be bought (already counting TF2, because he has the beta as well). I hope I'm wrong, but I don't think someone like this would give away a whole publisher pack

I gave away HIB #2 and I didn't have it on my steam account. -.- You guys ARE paranoid. And you're actually scaring users away. Give dude a chance, if he'll lie, he'll get his ban. Not that you can prove giveaway's fakeness.

I'm agreeing with Nintendo. So the guy's gifting very early in, so he doesn't have terribly many games. If you notice, he seems to have a lot of Source mods, so he may have dozens of games, just not ones logged through Steam. Nothing particularly suspicious here.

Well, he won't respond to me no matter what I do. I say it's fake, but that's me.

I think it might be fake as well and the way I see it, we're not paranoid. We just don't want someone winning it and becoming really happy only to find out it's fake.

I give him the benefit of the doubt, I guess we'll see if its a fake a week after the contest.