Minecraft

Idk, terraria was okay, but neverquest landmark should be on your radar since it will be free to play and have a pretty unique building/crafting system. If you want a crafting system with recipes I would lean to starbound I guess.

Terraria, mainly because I don't like the space theme that Starbound has.

Did not like Terraria, probably wont like Starbound either.

Can't decide.

Might as well as if you like space or not

It's a totally the same game under a different name and theme. If you like space stuff - starbound. And the only space stuff you'll get are suits.. If you don't like space stuff, go for Terraria.

Haven't played neither(I played Terraria a bit on my phone, but that doesn't count), so I'll go with Starbound.

I played Starbound with family sharing... I really want to buy it now. It's much better than Terraria.

I like the concept of Terraria very much, but, while still having a lot more "story" than Minecraft, it still doesn't convince me 100% in playing.
Starbound, already with its space setting and possibility to explore different worlds, has that little edge I wanted. On top of that I believe it will have even some more story (can anybody confirm this?).

TL;DR Starbound

Starbound is a rewritten version of Terraria. The Terraria code didn't allow for much extensions so they rewrote the code and build Starbound. I'm not down with the space-setting either, but the main game is on and inside planets anyway.

I like both. :-)

Terraria 2, which is a confirmed thing that is going to happen.

I like both, but Starbound has so much more to offer (or will once it's actually released) and improves on the formula greatly.

I have terraria and I don't like it I probably wont like Starbound either

I saw Starbound yesterday the first time (hi snake ^^) and it looked so cool. I cant compare it to Terraria, cuz I never played it myself. For the first look, I would choose Starbound :)

Starbound looks fun, but I'm not rushing to buy it like I did with Terraria. When I saw terraria (it hadn't even been released yet, just teaser videos), I was super hyped for it and bought it the second it released on steam, and I'm put 300+ hours into the game (Mainly because I would start up a new world with every major update that came out). Starbound doesn't look as good as terraria, not sure what it is, but it's like refined pixel art that doesnt look very good...like trying to make 16bit games HD with some filters. Anyway, I'll pick up starbound when it is on sale, or the small chance of winning it on this site.

TLDR; terraria

terraria is a great game. didnt try starbound yet

IMO both are pretty different but equally good.

Terraria > starbound

Just it!

Didn't play any of them, but Starbound looks better.

both but Starbound has much much more. . . .the whole game right now (in bug testing beta for the next two weeks) has at least 200X as much stuff in Terraria. I've just encountered vendors flown to thirteen different planets. . . setup a homebase. . . the music is epic. . . just all and all lots.

I only played Terraria but it's an awesome game!

Starbound isn't released yet.

I have to say that Starbound looks fascinating!