We are mutually whitelisted, just saying since you were asking for those who WLed you, I'm pretty sure you already knew since you entered in some WL exclusives tho :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Not sure if this adds to your post, but I'll tell you a little experiment I made yesterday doing a giveaway:
So I'm new to Steam/PC gaming and also new to SteamGifts. I did a few giveaways and was looking at the winners. Some had more than 7+ years in this platform and had NO Contribution on record but had Received Value.
At first I didn't care (I always think about those who can't afford it or young players) but then, I was reading some discussions about bots and I never realized the existences of BOTS. So, I did this experiment:
• I published a giveaway:
Started looking "right away" at the ENTRIES who applied the first seconds:
Most of them had a No Contribution and were registered 7+ years ago:
I decided to use the Blacklist function using my judgement on similar profiles assuming those were bots.
Then I kept looking at every entry and started to find out a big amount of users like this,... and also other kind of patterns...
Here is where you may come in:
• I noticed a pattern of profiles who were High Contributors Levels (7 or more) but all their giveaways were restricted (mostly with LOCK and a few with HEART) and had only 20 o less entries. BUT they were also enjoying and winning for regular unlocked giveaways. So I also decided to expand the use of the Blacklist function.
What I'm trying to say is that in my little experiment I have concluded:
• High level profile tend to use more the LOCKED (groups) option rather than whitelist.
• Some profiles take advantage of the Whitelist to level up.
• There is more "bots" than I imagined.
Nice meeting you. Hope sharing this info works for you to analyze the amount of open giveaways you see, but also check your stats to see how many people have blacklisted you (another reason why you can't see public giveaways).
Note: I'm going to create a Discussion for this topic to learn how everybody thinks about this.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes there are people doing so called circle jerks, only giving in small groups which is very unfortunate.
I even used to blacklist some of those people but with the limit i kinda stopped doing that and it felt pointless to spend too much time it, i haven't even blacklisted someone in over a year.
I am on 260 or so blacklists (i was different when i first joined and not everyone always liked my humor then and i think a portion of them are from people not even here anymore) against 1200+ whitelists, so that with as long as a new bundle is good (which often is with me, although for the first time in 3-4? years i haven't taken this months choice) i get them anyway and thus they also get filtered out. Mostly what i see are the endles adult games (or anything from the dig site) or people bought from example reseller sites.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm still quite new to SteamGifts so might not be elligble, but I'll throw my hat in the ring just in case..? :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Yeah sorry, still a bit early but you certainly are on the good path ratio wise, keep it up and you can always try again later.
Comment has been collapsed.
i dont have a lot of people whitelisted so ive never done a whitelist giveaway (yet!) but i am trying to give back as much as i receive :] (as much a college student can anyway). even if i don't fit every criteria very well, thought i could give it a try :3 cheers!!
Comment has been collapsed.
You still won more then you received, sorry it's a bit too early, but you are open to try again later.
Comment has been collapsed.
You got a bunch of 1 group entry giveaways on the other hand you are doing your best with puzzles, so okay i guess.
Comment has been collapsed.
Thanks, but you haven't done a whitelist yet for it to be useful but most of all you only have given a handful while your account exists several months, can't add you, sorry.
Comment has been collapsed.
I try to giveaway stuff somewhat regularly, haven't done many whitelist giveaways though as I don't have all that many people whitelisted cause I don't actively seek to whitelist people and only do so when I randomly come upon someone who I'd want on it.
Comment has been collapsed.
My account is 10 years old, but I've only actually started using SG around 2021. Even I'm not exactly sure how I came upon SG all the way back in 2014.
Comment has been collapsed.
I came across your thread and I've been trying to build my own whitelist so I've added you.
Comment has been collapsed.
Think you have been on my whitelist for a while, so I'll try my luck here!
Comment has been collapsed.
Noticed and decided to throw my hat in. I definitely should do more "Public" giveaways tho, it's been a while. Will accept whatever your decision is)
Comment has been collapsed.
Greetings. You're on my list. https://www.steamgifts.com/giveaway/zB1f6/necromunda-hired-gun
Comment has been collapsed.
You're on my list. https://www.steamgifts.com/giveaway/auIOE/the-falconeer-official-soundtrack
Have a nice day!
Comment has been collapsed.
Thank you.
Missing some public giveaways though, when you did feel free to ask again.
Comment has been collapsed.
I would like to check if I am eligible, added you on mine though anyways since you do great work in the community, specially with your music related puzzles/giveaways. Have participated in a few.
Comment has been collapsed.
Another here for simply letting you know, you have been on my WL! <3
Edit: Glad you just joined my WL giveaway. ^^
Comment has been collapsed.
Oh, I recognize that picture, you're the one with the music threads! I've used that trick a few times myself. Whitelisted you at some point.
I've never made a whitelist-only giveaway, but I typically add my whitelist to group giveaways.
Comment has been collapsed.
Sometimes i see people doing giveaways with both whitelist and group and not always easy to distinguish if they also got me whitelisted or that i am just part of a group, unless i dig into those groups or more so people that got me whitelisted but give away games that i already have (with my 12000) and therefor i can and will never see and thus return the favor. If you feel you are one of those, do comment that here (and let's be honest).
I know that there is a script for it i believe, but according to my stats i am already on 1200 people's whitelists but as when it comes to seeing giveaways i am only seeing 2-4 pages and if it's limited to 1000 on my side, i couldn't even add everyone if i wanted to, i wanted to set that straight.
However i am open to a few new people but some rules (i borrowed from amano):
-No leechers, if your ratio is too poor, forget it, i am not so much looking at the real cv part that is has to be 1:1 because it's not always a fair system, but come and get close and atleast in numbers it's prefered to have more sents then wins.
-No exploiters (50p crap games) and group circles (gifting only in groups with a selected amount of people).
-Have all your wins activated.
-You must do public giveaways on a regular base (atleast have done so in the past year).
-Therefor you must also do some whitelist giveaways per year, otherwise what's the use?
-Being active in a positive manner on the forum is a plus.
I am not going to reply to each and every person, if you get added you will see it yourself (or check) and it's probably totally random and it's not because i wouldn't like you but my remaining space is limited (and yes i should purge the inactives) but i also don't want it too full so a certain group that deserves it get a better chance on winning sometimes (it's what's it there for).
You can check here: https://www.steamgifts.com/giveaway/tuDxB/breakout-recharged
Comment has been collapsed.