If you cant fulfill a giveaway do you just get a bad track record?

He gets banned

or

He stays and he can make 1 or 2 giveaways before he can't.

Should get banned imho..

Step 1 - His feedback score is lowered (or stays 0)
Step 2 - The number of giveaways the user can create runs out
Step 3 - Admins/mods ban him eventually

It depends on context. If the person is misleading in the description, its a ban. If its by mistake, lowered percent rating when gift is marked not received. From experience, I think its best just to mark not received and hopefully the user creates more giveaways that do follow the rules.

He should be banned really. Anyone that lacks that much common sense has no business operating a computer without an anvil falling on their head.

Should get banned for being naughty

misunderstood the site?

Some guys think they get free games by creating giveaways?

hey guys so its day 6 and he already said hes not going to give it to me on day 1. when it hits day 7 do i just click not recieved and he gets banned?

by now its pretty clear hes not going to give it to you. you can try to contact him if you want (and if you havent already) to tell him you will contact the admin and he will likely get banned if he doesnt gift you the game you won.

if he ignores you or tells you he still wont gift you, then mark it as not recieved and inform the admin team... he will most likely get banned.

edit: now that i look at the guys account, it seems pretty clear he doesnt intend to use the site, so threatening him with a ban wont do anything. he WONT give you the game, so just mark it as not received, and tell the staff...