Am I allowed to gift this? Edit: (Solved-ish, now with gib)

You can gift them, no problem at all.

You are allowed to give away any extra copies after you activated yours. Though sometimes giveaway creators can wish them back if they specifically mentioned that, though it's not something that can be required.

Two conditions for making giveaways:

1) The game must be in the giveaway drop down list. Burning Man: Beyond Black Rock is.
2) The game must be redeemable in steam. Your gift copies are.

You're free to make giveaways for them!

If i were you, i would contact the giveaway creator and give it back. But i'm a strange guy that thinks that's the right thing to do :D
Anyway you can do with that extra copy whatever you want.

Hahaha I would be damn. I didn't know about the extra copy. I would of activated it myself. Oh well

I notice if you go an create a copy to gift on here the icon has on it that you also get 2 gift copies to give away...

So I wouldnt think you could do it because the copy you are giving away doesn't include two gift copies to give away and thus it's not true advertising of what your giveaway contains or actually yours wouldnt contain two extra give aways...

Can you make giveaways for them? Yes.
Should you make giveaways for them? That's up to you.
Should you return them to the creator? That's also up to you.

You won them, they come as part of the gift. What you do with them is up to you, as they're yours now.

I take that back -- after reading jeffhowe's comment above and checking it myself, it does appear that the two extra copies are part of the gift (purchase price), and for you to gift those extra copies, you're also responsible for delivering the +2 free copies per gift, since it's listed right on the giveaway itself (as well as the store page).

For future reference, when you get extra copies after activating a game they are tied to your region so if you are in a restricted region those extra copies are also restricted.

You seem to have sparked quite the conversation, friend!

Yes.

/thread

(Close it and stop wasting peoples keystrokes.)

let this keystroke be wasted!

You have them so you can gift them as far as I know

I think you should gift a copy to jeffhowe, for being the most helpful/accurate

Yes