Hello and Welcome to the central hub of SteamGifts Magazine!

The SG Community's own digital monthly gaming magazine in which ANYONE can join for a chance to win a game and review it, putting down their thoughts on "digital paper" for the whole community to read! Each submitted review will be published.

Steam Group Rules and Member Roles

Please make sure you have read and understood the rules for each role before requesting to join the Group:

Reviewer - As a reviewer you can enter the Group's giveaways for a chance to win games and review them.

The Rules:

1) Before entering giveaways, make sure you check the deadline assigned to them. Enter only if you truly believe that you can play and review the game in that timeframe. The deadline varies depending on game size and length, from 3 weeks up to a maximum of 8 weeks!

In case you cannot reach the expected deadline, you can request additional days in order to finish. A maximum of 5 additional days can be requested!

Not all games will require completion in order to be reviewed. Sport games, racing games, simulators or other type of "sandbox" games can be reviewed if a minimum required number of hours is met (that number will be decided separately).

Story based games on the hand, need to be finished before submitting the review!

2) Each Reviewer can enter any group giveaway until they win a game. After that point, the Reviewer is forbidden to enter additional giveaways unless they have played, reviewed, and submitted the review from the previously won giveaway.

3) There will be two giveaway 'waves' per month. Each wave will feature up to 15 giveaways.

4) In case you win multiple giveaways, you'll have to pick the game that you want to play and review the most, and then accept to re-roll the other game/s that you've won. This way everyone has a higher winning chance and you will be able to better focus on the review.

5) You’re not a professional game reviewer. We get that. Nobody is asking you to be one, but if you took upon yourself this task, you should at least try your best. We don’t want to stress you about creating the perfect review. But on the other hand, please respect the Magazine and the Group. Each review should be at least 1-2 pages long for smaller games, and 2-6 pages for bigger titles.

One page is measured in 400 words – font Calibri – size 11

Don’t worry if English isn’t your first language. It isn’t for most of us. I will correct mistakes the best I can before publishing it. Editors will help as well.

We also encourage a lighthearted approach in writing the review. Don’t take yourself too serious! Add some personal stories to make the reader feel more empathic towards you, rant about certain aspects of the game if you feel like it, make jokes, damn.. even add memes if you want to. The point is… be original. This is YOUR review. Pretend you’re explaining the game to your childhood's best friend. The reader is that friend :)

6) Do not try to copy/paste reviews from other sources. Stealing from others isn’t cool. And if caught you’ll be blacklisted. We want the authentic YOU!

7) The only “mandatory” review format is the game scoring. At the end of the review, you’ll have to score it accordingly to the magazine’s format.

8) As you play the game, you’ll be required to take and submit at least 5 in game screenshots, with small descriptions on what you were doing or trying to capture. These screenshots will be added in the magazine.

9) Some games might be too difficult to beat. Maybe you're stuck on a level? Or maybe the game is a mess filled with bugs that stops you from finishing it. If that's the case and you REALLY tried your best, but just couldn't move past a certain point, let us know in the Group. We can find a solution together.

10) The usage of any type of AI software or tool to write reviews or paragraphs from the review is strictly forbidden. We have an AI detection tool that we use on each submitted review, and it is highly effective, accurately identifying AI-generated content 9 out of 10 times.

If you are caught with 2 or less AI-generated paragraphs, you will receive a warning and lose your Premium membership (if you have one). If you are caught with more than 2 AI-generated paragraphs, you will be banned.

11) If you win a game, you have 7 days to redeem the key/gift and mark the game as received. Falling to do so will get you blacklisted.

12) Have a positive and friendly attitude.

Contributor – As a contributor you can support the Group with game giveaways (maximum of 4 per month). A game which will be reviewed by the winner and published in the magazine.

The Rules:

1) You’ll have to ask for permission before creating a Group giveaway. Via direct messaging me or requesting it in the dedicated post "Contributor's Dropxbox" in the Group Forum. The reason behind that is mostly because we’ll need to coordinate with the other giveaways. Also, no repeats of previous games.

2) There is going to be a limit of 4 giveaways per month (for the first few issues) and then, at a later date, the limit is going to be restricted to only 2 giveaway per month. The reason for that is because I want multiple members to participate on both sides. As a reviewer and a contributor. And since we can’t have too many giveaways going on at the same time, we need to limit the amount you can contribute.

3) Contributors will have a special "Thank You" section reserved in the magazine..

4) As a contributor you need to accept the fact that there is a small chance that some of your giveaways won't get to 5 entries. That means you will not receive any contributor points on SteamGifts.

5) Have a positive and friendly attitude.

Full Member – As a FM you’ll be able to contribute games for others to participate in, and you will also have access to other members giveaways for the purpose of playing & reviewing them.

Editor - As an editor, your task is to help us "tidy up" the reviews before we publish them in the Magazine. That means correcting any grammar mistakes you can find, making sure that the reviewer's ideas are well translated and interpreted into text. This is a vital role, as it will dictate the overall quality of the reviews and Magazine.

Moderator - Forum moderators will help with certain activities on the Steam Group Page. Making sure everyone is on their best behavior :)

Okay, now onto the Magazine..

Magazine Format

So far, this is very much up for debate. Everything you’ll see listed here are my own suggestions. By the time the magazine will be completed, many things will be changed or entirely new sections will be added.

TEAM OF THE MONTH section, in which the editors and all reviewers will be listed, alongside their games (and the page # in which the reader can find that specific review).
GAME GIVEAWAY section for the readers. Each issue will have a page dedicated to a game that is being given away through link invitation. The game will have a small review on it’s own. The giveaway will end on the last day of the month, right before the next issue is published. There might be multiple copies of the game in the same giveaway so more readers get a chance at it.
SPECIAL section for different kind of articles related to gaming.
NEWS section for gaming news.
HANDS-ON REVIEW for games contributed by developers. If any indie game developers want to advertise their game and are looking for a honest review. (This might not be available in the first issue).
REVIEWS section.
COVER GAME REVIEW section, is going to be the “big” or “main” review. Which shall be the longest and most detailed (also the bigger game of them all).
SCREENSHOT OF THE MONTH section, in which ALL SteamGifts members can submit their favourite screenshot from any game. Only 3 will be selected for publication. 3rd place, 2nd place and the winner. (don't know yet where they should submit the photos)
FREE2PLAY GAME OF THE MONTH section, in which we’ll feature a Steam game that is free to play.
HYPE section, in which we list a few upcoming releases that we’re hyped for.
CONTRIBUTOR “Thank You” section in which all members that contributed with games will be mentioned. Each of them having a quote underneath the game they’ve gifted.
And more… (if you have any suggestion, please share!)

The Rating System

I decided against using a conventional 10 digits or percentage scoring method.

Instead, the rating system for each game will be the following:

Story – Based on overall storyline, sidequests, environment, characters and dialogue.
Graphics – Based on overall graphics capabilities, visual effects and how well they hold up (for older games).
Sound – Based on sound effects, music and voice acting.
Gameplay – Based on gameplay mechanics, fluidity of the game, learning curve and engine stability.
Fun Meter – Based on originality and how much you’ve enjoyed playing it.

For EACH of these categories you need to assign a number of stars.
⭐ - horrible
⭐ ⭐ - poor
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ - good
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ - very good
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ - perfect

Besides the star system, we’ll also use a “VERDICT” section in which you can list up to 5 positives and 5 negatives of the game.

In the end, the reviewer will have to choose between “Approved” or “Rejected” on the “Seal of Recommendation”.

List of Reviews in Progress here

List of available Games (Wave 12 - Limited "Lost & Found" Wave):

Game Genre Deadline Comment
BioShock™ Remastered FPS / Atmospheric / Horror 10th of February Review is optional
Sam & Max Save the World Adventure / Point & Click / Puzzle 10th of February Review is optional
Outlast Horror / Survival / Atmospheric 10th of February Review is optional
Emily is Away <3 Simulation / Indie / Choices Matter 10th of February Review is optional
Ceville Adventure / Point & Click / Fantasy 10th of February Review is optional
TEKKEN 7 Fighting / Action / Arcade 10th of February Review is optional
DiRT Rally Rally / Simulator / Racing 10th of February Review is optional
Alan Wake Collector's Edition Action / Horror / Adventure 10th of February Review is optional
Bastion Action / Indie / Adventure 10th of February Review is optional
Trek to Yomi Action / Hack & Slash / Adventure 10th of February Review is optional
Wolfenstein 3D Action / FPS / Retro 10th of February Review is optional
Lemon Cake Casual / Farming Sim / Cute 10th of February Review is optional
Resident Evil 4 (2005) Action / Horror / Retro 10th of February Review is optional
Hotline Miami Action / Violent / Indie 10th of February Review is optional
ECHO Action / Stealth / Sci-Fi 10th of February Review is optional
Clustertruck Action / First Person / Funny 10th of February Review is optional
Red Faction®: Armageddon™ Action / Third Person / Sci-Fi 10th of February Review is optional
Smoke and Sacrifice RPG / Adventure / Indie 10th of February Review is optional
CivCity: Rome Strategy / City Builder / Historical 10th of February Review is optional
Ice Age Scrat's Nutty Adventure Adventure / Platformer / Family Friendly 10th of February Review is optional
Risen Open World / RPG / Fantasy 10th of February Review is optional
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor GOTY Action / RPG / Fantasy 10th of February Review is optional
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor GOTY Action / RPG / Fantasy 10th of February Review is optional
Psychonauts Adventure / Platformer / Retro 10th of February Review is optional
Mortal Kombat 11 Fighting / Violent / Arcade 10th of February Review is optional
Split/Second Racing / Action / Arcade 10th of February Review is optional
UNSIGHTED RPG / Action / Adventure 10th of February Review is optional
Moonscars Souls-like / Action / Platformer 10th of February Review is optional
Dusk Diver 酉閃町 Beat 'em Up / Action / RPG 10th of February Review is optional
Vane Adventure / Action / Exploration 10th of February Review is optional
Retimed Funny / Casual / Platformer 10th of February Review is optional
Morkredd Physics / Puzzle / Exploration 10th of February Review is optional
Levelhead Platformer / Difficult / Funny 10th of February Review is optional
Pathologic 2 RPG / Choices Matter / Atmospheric 10th of February Review is optional
Not Tonight Indie / Adventure / Multiple Endings 10th of February Review is optional
Warhammer: Chaosbane Action / Adventure / RPG 10th of February Review is optional
Vampire: The Masquerade - Shadows of New York Visual Novel / Fantasy / Vampires Deadline not required Already reviewed
Trine 4: The Nightmare Prince Platformer / Adventure / Puzzle 10th of February Review is optional
Partisans 1941 Strategy / War / Historical 10th of February Review is optional
River City Girls Beat 'em Up / Action / Cute 10th of February Review is optional
The Letter Visual Novel / Horror / Mature 10th of February Review is optional
DARK SOULS™ III RPG / Dark Fantasy / Souls-like 10th of February Review is optional
Horizon Zero Dawn™ Complete Edition RPG / Open World / Adventure 10th of February Review is optional
Lovingly Evil Romance / Visual Novel / Cute 10th of February Review is optional
If My Heart Had Wings Romance / Visual Novel / Cute 10th of February Review is optional
Max, an Autistic Journey Indie / RPG / Horror 10th of February Review is optional
Richard & Alice Adventure / Point & Click / Mystery 10th of February Review is optional
Gorogoa Puzzle / Indie / Casual 10th of February Review is optional
Donut County Puzzle / Cute / Casual 10th of February Review is optional
RESTLESS SOUL Adventure / Cute / Funny 10th of February Review is optional
The Forgotten City Adventure / RPG / Mystery 10th of February Review is optional
Disco Elysium - The Final Cut Choices Matter / RPG / Detective 10th of February Review is optional
Chivalry 2 Action / Gore / Medieval 10th of February Review is optional
The Tarnishing of Juxtia Action / RPG / Souls-like 10th of February Review is optional
Red Faction Guerrilla Re-Mars-tered Action / FPS / Sci-Fi 10th of February Review is optional
Obey Me Action / Indie / Adventure 10th of February Review is optional
Storm Boy Cute / Indie / Adventure 10th of February Review is optional
Eastern Exorcist Action / RPG / Adventure 10th of February Review is optional
Lost Castle / 失落城堡 Action / Roguelike / Beat 'em Up 10th of February Review is optional
My Time at Portia RPG / Open World / Cute 10th of February Review is optional
SCP: Secret Files Adventure / Story Rich / Mystery 10th of February Review is optional
Prodeus FPS / Action / Gore 10th of February Review is optional
WWE 2K23 Sports / Wrestling / Simulation 10th of February Review is optional
Hardspace: Shipbreaker Space / Sci-Fi / Simulation 10th of February Review is optional
Sands of Salzaar Strategy / RPG / Open World 10th of February Review is optional
Vampyr Vampire / RPG / Open World 10th of February Review is optional
Bear and Breakfast Adventure / RPG / Relaxing 10th of February Review is optional
Tinykin Adventure / Action / Platformer 10th of February Already reviewed
GOD EATER 3 Hack & Slash / Action / JRPG 10th of February 10th of February
Parkasaurus Management / Sim Building / Dinosaurs 10th of February 10th of February
CODE VEIN Action / Souls-like / Anime Deadline not required Already reviewed

Finished reviews can be submitted directly to staff member via Discord or Steam. Just message any of us and we'll take it from there.

How to Join the Group?

If you've read the rules and want to be part of the team, please leave a comment here with your desired role, then request to join here

Join our Discord..

if you want to say hi or submit your game screenshot for the "Screenshot of the Month" contest.

Screenshot of the Month

You have a cool, artistic or funny game screenshot that you want to share with us? Then submit it to us on Discord in the submission channel!

At the end of each month we're going to set up a vote poll for the best submission. The winner will be added in the Magazine's "Screenshot of the Month" section!

Submit your favourite screenshot on our Discord channel or on the Steam Group Page here.

Additional Info

After the first issue is released, we’ll have a monthly vote on “best review”, which will grant the winner the option to chose from 3 games. The won game can be reviewed for the next month's issue, but it is not mandatory.

Magazine Index

Issue # Month Thread Magazine PDF Version
1 March X X X
2 April X X X
3 May X X X
4 June X X X
5 July X X X
6 August X X X
7 September X X X
8 October X X X
9 November X X X
10 December X X X

edit: Please comment here, or on Discord, your desired Group role before submitting a request to join. We have received many requests with no info attached. WE CANNOT ACCEPT THEM unless you specify your desired role first!

1 year ago*

Comment has been collapsed.

Hi, I would like to join as a contributor.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello!

Request to join the Group and I’ll add you to the Members List :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sent :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Bump!

Less than 3 hours until the first wave of giveaways end. If you want to join and review for the first issue of the magazine, now would be the time! :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

i lost :(

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

better luck on the next wave :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Just wanted to say congratulations to the winners. I am kind of excited to see the 1st issue of Steamgifts magazine. :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hear! Hear!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Bump.

Wave 2 giveaways active!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Bump.

New giveaways added!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sounds interesting. I would like to join as a Reviewer.

Can I post my written reviews on Steam as well? :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Added! Welcome :)

And yes, I don't see a reason why not. But in case of winning and reviewing a game for the Magazine, please post the review on Steam only AFTER the Magazine is published.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello,

Please be aware that currently you are in violation of rule 2.

2) Each Reviewer can enter up to 3 giveaways per giveaway "wave"!

You're participating in Death's Door, Nex Machina, Days Gone and One Step From Eden. That's 4/3.

I'd hate to give you a warning for it when the giveaways end. Read the rules carefully!

Thanks.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Ah, thank you! Forgot about that.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I wonder if you need that rule, when you got Reviewer rule 4) Only one win per wave. That way you could also be off with Contributor rule 4) about the higher risk of no CV, making it more attractive to give away games in your group.

  • Not to mention save yourself a ton of work, if the group grows. But a script might make that a moot point!

There is also the sad edge case, where a giveaway might be left without a winner, due to low entries or that the entrants all won another giveaway and chose that game. That risk might seem low, but if everyone chooses their top 3, then the tendency is that they will deprioritize the same games.

All that said, I understand that the rule makes it more likely that the winner will play and review the game, which I'm sure is your top priority!

Maybe making the giveaways private would help make it easier to remember. Although I digress; that's another rule xD

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Heya I would like to join as a full member if that's possible!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Added!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello. The idea seem interesting to me. Is there some sample review I could see before I can apply? Also can I review games bought not won?

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello,

There is no review template or sample. If you chose to participate and you actually win a game, you'll have to write 1-2 pages for smaller titles and 2-6 for bigger titles. 1 page is measured in 400 words, calibri font, size 11. The only other requirement is that at the end you use the Magazine's game rating format. Other than that.. it's creative freedom.

You can join the group as a Reviewer and wait for the first issue to see what kind of reviews there are. You don't have to join giveaways if you're not prepared.

And for your last question. No. You can't review your own games for the Magazine. It has to be the ones from the current list.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I think that's a good idea. I would like to join as a reviewer then

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Send a group request and I'll add you :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Okay sent :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello! The SGM team has some concerns regarding your Destroy all humans review. I'll be straight to the point: did you by any chance use any external tools to help you write your review, such as chatGPT or any other language model?

I'm sorry about contacting you about this so publicly, but given you didn't respond to my friend request on Steam, and we don't think you're in our discord, I didn't see any other options.

9 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hi. Yes I wrote the review and asked chatgpt to fix grammatical mistakes and rephrase it like Ricky gervais wrote it (love his style of humor). English isnt my first language so I usually ask chatgpt to fix any mistakes. I thought a satirical tone would fit the game so I aksed chatgpt to rephrase it. Let me know if it doesnt work for you then I can give the original version.

PS: I am on dthe discord channel by the name Dan

9 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

is there a new discord link? this one is expired, or is it only for the steam group members?

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Fixed! :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Bump!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Bump!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Bump!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

hello,
i just noticed that the new waves giveaways already end on 15th February.
i thought the magazine will be a monthly issue and thought there would be 1 wave per month. so i expected the new wave to end on 1st march.
was wondering what the background/thought process for more waves was.
not criticizing, just wondering

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

probably to have enough time to play, review and edit the magazine

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

lol i thought more waves in shorter time would give you less time to do all that

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Having a constant flux of games being given away and revievwed, so we don't depend on the first wave.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hi - thanks for doing this! I'm interested in becoming a reviewer. Is there a possibility to become a contributor" if we decide we want to give away a game for review sometime in the future? Thanks!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello,

Added you as a Reviewer! And sure, you can ask for a role change later on :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

bump!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

when would you like some giveaways

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hey, thanks. We could use some in the next wave starting on 15th of February :)

Send a group request so I can add you to the members list!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

thanks but can my son add your group instead as i t will be much easier talking with him than trying to catch me on Steam

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sure, just let me know what his Steam username is, and I will accept his request.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

i can't add him as it seems to be a private group but if you could add him https://steamcommunity.com/id/justseedy/

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

thanks also ask us both to join the group as well thanks and we can talk about giveaways

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Done! I will add you both to the members list as Contributors.

Please message me or comment here before creating any Group giveaways.

For Wave 2 we have enough giveaways, since the Group doesn't have that many members yet and most of the giveaways have very few entries. But you or your son can contribute in Wave 3 (starting after 15th of February).

Thanks once again for the support!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

This is really cool! I would like to apply as reviewer if possible :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Deleted

This comment was deleted 1 year ago.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Deleted

This comment was deleted 1 year ago.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Bump!

Come join the group. We have cookies.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

can i join as reviewer?

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

You sure can, stranger. Come in! Send a group request and I'll add you to the members list.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Deleted

This comment was deleted 9 months ago.

9 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hi there ! Really love the idea !

I'd like to help aswell, if it is possible ?
I would like to join as a full member. I'm really NOT confident of my redacting skill tho. So i'd probably be giving more than actually join giveways. At least, for the begining.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello!

We'd love to have you as part of the Group.

Please send a group request and I shall add you to the members list :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sounds fun, id like to join as FM

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Added! :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sent a request through :)
I would love to participate in this. If you'd like to see my review skill (or lack there of) have a look at the reviews I posted on Steam thus far. Getting a game specifically for review purposes seems like a fun concept to me.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Would you like to join the Group as a Reviewer?

If so, just make sure you've read the rules and then send a group request. I'll add you to the members list soon after.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

maybe adding a poll to be talked about the next issue would be great as well maybe something like:

should dlc for games costing £50+ be free or which game do you wish could/would come to PC

I would also very much be willing to mention this via my sons group on Steam

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Any publicity is good publicity.

Regarding the poll, we're trying not to overflow the SG's discussions board with too many threads. Besides this one (the Central Hub), we'll have an additional thread + vote poll created so that members can vote for the "Screenshot of the Month" section, and an additional monthly thread when the magazine is released. A thread in which members can openly discuss the "current' issue and the reviews.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

:)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Bump!

Wave 3 of giveaways started!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

bump - my copy of bang bang racing is live as a giveaway

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello, have requested access to the group. Feel free to read some of my more serious reviews. They range from 800 to 2,400 words. Interesting concept you have here.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello,

Are you interested in joining as a Reviewer?

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Yes I am. Assuming my reviews are something the team is happy with.

Happy to chat over Steam/Discord/VC if you've anything specific you'd like to run through.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Okay. Added :)

Feel free to join us on Discord anytime!

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Appears the Discord link won't allow me to join

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

That's really weird. What does it say?

https://discord.gg/KZG4kpF5XG

I've tested it and it works just fine..

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

bump - some games still have no entries - i wonder if this will be the biggest problem here - i mean i have no problem adding giveaways but not if i will keep getting 0 entries - i wonder how many reviewers we really have

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hello,

We are aware of that. The group is new and still small. For the giveaways that will end with zero entries we have 2 options:

  1. Remake it for the next wave.
  2. Remake it as a regular giveaway but advertise the Group in the description.

It's up to you to decide what to do with it after this wave :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

thanks

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

My two cents (as a reviewer) - I just played Just Cause 4 in February. While I had a lot of fun reviewing it, it also took a lot of time to play the game, write the review, and organize the screenshots. I decided not to review any other game for at least a month or two, mainly because I needed a break. Once you pick a game to review you also gain some responsibility, to the GA creator and to the community. That means that choosing to review a game is not something I take lightly.

For instance, Sleeping Dogs keep showing up in my Wishlist as a GA I should join since it has 0 entries. But every time I see it's from the SG Magazine group, I decide not to join it (for now) because I wouldn't be able to do justice to the review given my available time right now.

If you really want to have GAs going over the 5 entries (or even over 1 entry), I would consider the following points:

  • Do not giveaway free games, since some people might use the opportunity to be a reviewer as a way to access games they have been interested in for a while and wouldn't be able to get for free (at least that's how I think about it)
  • Focus on unbundled games - there are a few games I would like to review but I already got on Humble Choice or on a recent Fanatical bundle
  • For games with long times to beat: give a lot of time to the reviewer. 8 weeks is easier on the reviewer than 6 weeks, and 6 weeks is easier than 4 weeks
  • All else being equal, games with shorter times to beat would have more entries than games with longer times to beat

Anyway, I hope that a reviewer's perspective helps in some way. Also remember that even though I'm a reviewer, I'm not up to reviewing games on every wave, since being a reviewer is a serious commitment :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

thanks that is some very interesting points and some that i never considered before - i wasn't complaining - i was just concerned about the amount of 0 giveaways still - i love making giveaways for many groups and no groups at different levels and for my whitelist (add you) - i hope it didn't come across as me being mean or upset with this and of course i will support this magazine both with giveaways and promotion where possible still and in the future - i will say that most of your points are the reason that i only asked to be a contributor of giveaways and not a reviewer

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

It didn't come across as negative at all! I do follow a lot of your other frequent GAs hehe and I'm very grateful for your contribution to the community. I'm glad some of the points I brought up are new to you - that was the whole intention of my post :)

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I think it will naturally level out with more users in the group.

I mean Bang bang Racing is a fine game. But if I enter for it, being the sole entry I am basically automatically choosing to play that one.
Since I am more interested in We Are Happy Few, of course I will hope more for the lesser chance of getting that, then 100% of getting less desired game by completely ridding me of chance of getting something more to my liking.

It's a bit like snowball effect - if only 2-3 people entered your giveaway, I would choose it as well as then I would have someone else to ask to reroll to in case I win something else. I mean I could be a dick and refuse accepting but Im not sure if rules even allow that. Same goes for other games in this wave as well - I woudn't mind entering more but I don't want to be the only one entering.

1 year ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Closed 1 month ago by AtomicBlonde.