Just offer both in the graphic settings =) (and having the no AA by default). The text is more readable with the no AA one.

Wait, is it for a game? It looks like it...

I like the anti-aliasing one slightly better, non anti-aliasing seems to be better with the gradient layers

I prefer the No-AA one, shows all more clear.

I hate Aliasing. Unless you are aiming at an absolute-retro style, I would always recommend the AA.

At the very least, AA version has illegible text. So non-AA.

I prefer the one without anti-aliasing.

No anti-aliasing at all :)

Well it depends on the style you're looking to achieve, in any case you can just add it as an option.

Personally i like both.

However if you do choose to go with AA, you'd have to fix the text, cant be understood like that D:

The resolutions aren't identical, so I can't give an accurate answer. :(

Depends on what you want the feel of the game to be. Retro, no anti-aliasing. Functional and smooth, anti-aliasing.

I like it without.

Whatever you choose, give me a beta key to whatever it is.

never fails - just can't be one or the other - the buildings and objects look better WITH and the characters and text look better WITHOUT

you can check my avatar

Anyone else think this was a thread about a drink?

Non AA for readable text.

I prefer no AA but if you can include both that would be ideal.

I like the anti-aliased one.

The better question is why the fuck are you not on Steam right now?

Or better yet...

That said they look exactly the same to my untrained eye.

With a bit of tweaking, I think the AA one would have a nice and unique-ish feeling and maybe some non-old-school kiddos will like the game style too. The AA one would need to have some details added after AA, like the eyes and fix some corner borders (like on the flags) or even make the borders less obvious.
But if you can and have the time, an option to change that in-game would be the best option.

8X

No AA.

I usualy prefer 2x AA

8x Whatcha buildin ?

Give the user the choice. :-p

Imo the AA looks terribly like just another flash game. The 8-bit style is a little less chliché.