My perception, based on similar experience of winning 2 or 3 in a seemingly quick succession, then nothing for month on end, it seems streaky.
Comment has been collapsed.
I think userid plays a role as well. I have a winner of my GA, who won alot of games and is not to old on the site as well, and his userID is a mix of numbers and letters. Either he is very smart and very lucky to win so many games, or his userid is favored by the algorithm as he might be popping up is random picks alot. 62 wins in 5 months is quite a luck
Comment has been collapsed.
Comment has been collapsed.
are you entering enough? I had a pretty high count before I won my first game - something over 1000 entries I think. You might look at joining some groups. I'm a member of the Arise Group, and it might be something you want to look into. Good group w/ lots of giveaways everyday. I'm sure there are others, but that's the one I'm familiar with.
http://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/8VyDB/arise-giveaway-group-recruiting
Comment has been collapsed.
It's human nature to attempt to align patterns in environments of randomness. Simply take a visit to any casino.
Comment has been collapsed.
I do seem to win in streaks, whenever I win a game I seem to win a couple more in the following week and then nothing for months, but I know perfectly well it's all random so I don't worry about it.
Comment has been collapsed.
you should erase the /r in the strawpoll link, thats the link for the results
And i dont know what to say, i've had those "streaks" before (not so many games btw) but i dont think theres a way for it not to be random? maybe a queue or something like that
Comment has been collapsed.
As soemone who havent won a single item in my life ( including all steam giveaway sites ) i can confirm that this is not random.
Comment has been collapsed.
I've always had bad luck when RNG is involved... so I'm used to it. Someday my luck has to turn I keep hoping... :D
Comment has been collapsed.
Streaky! what I don't get is why? isn't it better to win really randomly?
Comment has been collapsed.
I definitely noticed this, too.
Many people won in a row from me, even when the giveaways ended 30 minutes apart. The same happened to my boyfriend when we made trains together. Some users even won from me and from him in the same event. I feel like the "randomization" has something to do with the entry time or other factors...
And also: I check every single person that wins something from me, e.g. if they have multiple wins etc. and also if they regifted... So by checking many many "won pages" of people, I noticed A LOT, really A LOT LOT LOT of times that users won from the same person multiple games in a row.
I'm really interested in the algorithm and I cannot really believe that it's pure randomization.
Comment has been collapsed.
Many of the replies make me think maybe there's something in the randomization that rank/sorts by user i.d. for a period of time, rather then generate an independent random choice per giveaway. Perhaps there are computational benefits or other reasons for doing something other than pure random selection per giveaway?
Of course, we might be seeing patterns that aren't there, but if I was a stock trader (which I am on occasion) I think I'm picking up a trading signal and would go long when I get a win because odds of another one soon seem to improve.
Comment has been collapsed.
One of my winners won 2 games within half an hour so yes it does happen.
Comment has been collapsed.
I usually win nothing the entire week and then i win 2 or 3 GA's on 1 day usually on weekends
Comment has been collapsed.
For everyone that thinks something might be "wrong" with Steamgifts random algorithm:
THROW A COIN 1000 TIMES!!!
(or read the first page of this paper).
See those long streaks of Heads (or Tails) in a row, right there?
Yeah.
For 1000 flips of a fair coin, the expected value of the longest run is about 10.
Comment has been collapsed.
I think overall the place is random (certainly I don't think anyone has a way to deliberately abuse the system). But I know when I was obsessed with Pokemon RNG abuse and manipulation was a thing and I sometimes suspect there are certain things going on here due to pseudorandom number generation rather than true random number generation. My own wins have come in clusters and anecdotal evidence suggests this is fairly common, and although I'm the first to admit that could simply be a matter of statistics and human tendencies to seek patterns rather than true anomalies, I have perhaps more significantly noticed serious issues with large trains I have made.
I have done some pretty big trains in forums and noticed multiple games going to various winners. With, for instance, 65 giveaways in a train and a limited number of people paying attention to the hidden link the chances of a multiple winner are pretty high. But I have often had several people winning several games in a single train, and as the sets of data from said trains were seemingly more manageable and suitable for mathematical statistical analysis I was able to sit down and start to determine some probabilities. And I'm pretty sure the chances of some of the specific clusters that occur here time and time again being genuinely random are pretty remote...
Comment has been collapsed.
Streaky; normally I win a GA or two per week but I managed just recently to get two in one day!
Comment has been collapsed.
I've entered 7294 giveaways. Won 61. It would be nice to be able to calculate the exact average number of entries, but I'd risk saying 0.836% is a fairly consistent result.
I have also won in streaks, but those are easily explained by either a large number of giveaways ending in a given day (e.g. christmas), or by having entered consecutive invite-only or group giveaways.
Comment has been collapsed.
some necroposting.
Those streaks again, i won 2 games in a day(week ago) and after that. The streak of unluck of course. Over 200 hundred giveaways with less than 150 entries, 100 with less than 50, over 50 giveaways with less than 30 entries. And no aney luck.
I know, i'm just stupid shameless guy =_=. I just used to be lucky guy.
So, lil giveaway for people who suffered from reading my post.
http://www.steamgifts.com/giveaway/LAdzX/knights-of-pen-and-paper-1-deluxier-edition
Comment has been collapsed.
computers do have an algorythm for random numbers, unlike what a quantum computer would have.
In coding softwares I've encountered clusters of numbers being repeated in random number generators. I have no idea why it is so but for the most of the time it should not do that. It may also depend on the coding software being used.
Comment has been collapsed.
391 Comments - Last post 5 minutes ago by kiseli
16,858 Comments - Last post 7 minutes ago by mapcoreuser
6 Comments - Last post 12 minutes ago by pb1
2,655 Comments - Last post 24 minutes ago by Calibr3
1,179 Comments - Last post 39 minutes ago by Formidolosus
300 Comments - Last post 52 minutes ago by CutieTheRooster
20 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by ziuq
78 Comments - Last post 1 minute ago by m0r1arty
59 Comments - Last post 6 minutes ago by RobbyRatpoison
66 Comments - Last post 9 minutes ago by GoatPimp
151 Comments - Last post 20 minutes ago by Beauregarde
1,567 Comments - Last post 47 minutes ago by A10i
1,719 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by A10i
8,623 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Butterkatt
Hi all, I just had a wow moment that made me ask this question.
I just had the same person win two giveaways with 394 and 438 entries that ended 1 minute apart. The probability of that happening is 0.0000058 assuming randomness (or pseudo randomness w/ an algo and seed).
I've also noticed that when I win, I also often win in bunches. That can happen with randomness for sure, but it feels a bit clustery sometimes.
I'm curious, do any of you get the feeling that maybe winning isn't random on a per giveaway basis, but maybe some days you're streaky? Just curious.
And I'm not insinuating anything improper is going on, I'm just trying to understand if something about the selection algorithm might make streakiness more probable? Is it a simple rand(n), where n is # of entrants, or is it perhaps somehow tied to particular user id's on certain days that makes winning more probable? If it's been explained somewhere that'd be cool to read. thanks
EDIT: Link to Poll as provided by rred (thanks)
http://strawpoll.me/6225603
Comment has been collapsed.