Can anyone else confirm these?

Sapper's Bad Dream - DIG Desura Bundle 5 / DIG Super Bundle 70 (?)
Go Mission Space travel - DIG Greenlight Bundle 6 / DIG Greenlight Bundle 7. Keys from DIG Super Bundle 69 still work.
Miracle Fly - DIG Super Bundle 58
SOUNDTRACK? OK! from Go Go Bundle Mega #21
Blind Men - IndieGala Kawaii Anime Bundle
Marble Duel - HeroCraft Bundle #1
Safety Driving Simulator: Car
Bye-Bye, Wacky Planet from Parallel Worlds Bundle (Cubic Bundle)
Hoven the Sages Spinel from Abstract Cubic Bundle


More games with invalidated keys can be found here.


Updates:

Reported, but waiting to be added when time allows:
Dungeon Creepster | Go Go Bundle Mega #16 & Go Go Bundle Mega #25
Maze Run VR | Otaku Bundle #12
Gump Runner | Cubic August Bundle Vol. 2
Pic Guesser | Cubic August Bundle Vol. 2
The Prism | May Cubic Bundle
Rooks Keep | May Cubic Bundle
SEXXXNATOR: Adult Sandbox RPG | giveaway.su = Keys completely revoked from your library
Sex City | giveaway.su = Keys completely revoked from your library
Hentai Petting Simulator | giveaway.su = Keys completely revoked from your library
Skull Rush | IndieGala - Indie Rocket Bundle
SecondSpeed | IndieGala - Monday Motivation #24

 

Full update log


Games whose unused keys have been invalidated (you will still have it in your library, but unredeemed keys show as dupes)

Game Bundles affected What can you do? Related threads & comments Revocation / Reported Date Notes
The Uncertain: Last Quiet Day IndieGala - Hump Day Bundle #62 - SG Comment Sep 29 2019 -
Truth Of Falchion Go Go Bundle #55 - SG comment Sep 29 2019 -
Sugar Box IndieGala - Monday Motivation Bundle #40 - SG comment Sep 29 2019 -
SWEATER? OK! Go Go Bundle Mega #21 - SG Comment Sep 26 2019 Unsure if DLC keys still work.
Taimumari Hardcore Cubic Bundle - SG Comment Sep 26 2019 -
Angels of Fasaria: Version 2.0 ? - SG Thread Sep 22 2019 Keys from Groupees - Build a Bundle 61 still work.
Mortificatio Go Go Bundle #47 - SG Comment Sep 16 2019 -
Red Lake Go Go Bundle Mega #5 - SG Comment Sep 13 2019 -
Robot Warriors Bunch Keys Bundle #30 & Go Go Bundle #29 & Go Go Bundle Mega #13 fabiobh@hotmail.com.br SG Comment Sep 08 2019 -
NeoBalls2 Bunch Keys Bundle #30 bjgameind@gmail.com SG Comment Sep 08 2019 Some keys might still work
Burning Instinct Otaku Bundle #37 the.merlin.99@gmail.com SG Comment Sep 08 2019 -
Operation Desert Road Go Go Bundle Mega #11 & Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Sep 07 2019 Keys from Bunch Keys Bundle #12 still work
Golf 2D Go Go Bundle Mega #11 & Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Sep 07 2019 Keys from Bunch Keys Bundle #12 still work
Space Way Go Go Bundle Mega #11 & Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Sep 07 2019 Keys from Bunch Keys Bundle #12 still work
Brick Breaker Ultimate Go Go Bundle Mega #11 & Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Sep 07 2019 Keys from Bunch Keys Bundle #12 still work
Space Rocket Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Sep 07 2019 -
Bitcoin Farm Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Sep 07 2019 Keys from Bunch Keys Bundle #12 still work
Race Go Go Bundle Mega #18Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Sep 07 2019 -
Solar System Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Sep 07 2019 Keys from Bunch Keys Bundle #12 still work
Hammer 2 Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Sep 07 2019 Keys from Bunch Keys Bundle #12 still work
The Extinction IndieGala - Indie Break Off Bundle & IndieGala - Hump Day #17 & Groupees - Shoppaholic and Knuckles 3 Greenlight Bundle - Steam Thread Sep 03 2019 Unknown: Fanatical - Blazing Bundle is unknown.
Die for the Empire IndieGala - The Indie Crusade Bundle - Steam thread Sep 03 2019 -
SnakEscape Go Go Bundle Mega #20 & Go Go Bundle #38 . - SG comment Aug 22 2019 The keys for SnakEscape: Soundtrack still work.
Furry Girl 🐺 giveaway.su & dev keys - SG Comment Aug 09 2019 All non-beta keys were deactivated by Valve.
BORIS the Mutant Bear with a Gun Monday Motivation Bundle #56 ducat@borisgame.com - the dev answers, but slowly Steam Thread & SG comment Aug 14 2019 -
The Away Team: Lost Exodus Groupees - Be Mine 29 & IndieGala - Monday Motivation #24 & Fanatical - Mega Pick & Mix Bundle 7 Email: support@awayteam.space Steam Thread & SG Comment Jul 29 2019 Dev is lying about the contract.
Legend of the Skyfish Groupees - Build a Bundle #53 Submit a ticket to Groupees for a replacement SG Comment Jul 29 2019 -
Measurment Problem IndieGala - Friday Special Bundle #40 - Steam Thread Jul 08 2019 Developers changed game title to PLAYERUNKNOWN'S BATTLEGRОUNDS on June 24. Valve banned the game and renamed it to App 534960.
What's under your blanket !? IndieGala - Frontline Assault Bundle, IndieGala - Go Postal Bundle, IndieGala - XXL Winter Bundle Try info@5wolf.ru or prensa@5wolf.ru Steam Thread Jul 01 2019 -
Christmas Race Go Go Bundle Mega #11 & Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - SG Comment Jun 26 2019 Christmas Race 2 from GoGo Mega 20 is NOT dupe at this time
Retro Sphere Groupees - Build a Bundle 44 - SG comment Jun 24 2019 Additional keys received from Groupees support are also dupes.
Gravity Ball Go Go Bundle Mega #11 & Go Go Bundle Mega #18 - Steam Thread Jun 21 2019 Keys from Bunch Keys Bundle #12 still work.
Age of Steel: Recharge Take-Off Mega Bundle - Steam Thread Jun 23 2019 -
PooSky Cubic Bundle - One Dollar Bundle #5 & Go Go Bundle Limited #50 - SG comment Jun 21 2019 It is unknown if keys from other bundles work.
AquaSnap Window Manager Groupees - Steam Software Bundle - Steam Thread 1 & Steam Thread 2 Jun 04 2019 -
PomboTroll Bunch Keys Bundle #32 & DIG Store - SG comment Jun 03 2019 -
AoF Chess Club 2.0 ? - SG comment Jun 01 2019 -
Fasaria World Online Indiegala - Every Monday Bundle #96 ? - May 31 2019 -
KORABLIK Indiegala - Monday Motivation #25 - Steam Thread May 30 2019 -
H.E. DIG Weekly Bundle 31 and lequeshop ? - - May 23 2019 Reported, but unconfirmed
Pineview Drive Groupees - The 50 - Haunting Bundle - Steam thread May 22 2019 Unknown if Indiegala or Fanatical bundles are affected.
Catorize IndieGala - Friday Special #25 - Steam thread May 14 2019 -
Zombie Zoeds IndieGala - Hump Day Bundle #9 & CCYY May Day Bundle & DIG Store - Steam Thread May 07 2019 -
My Super Tower 2 IndieGala - The Indie Realms Bundle & Go Go Bundle Mega #20 Email to: support@rockpathcollective.com Steam Thread May 14 2019 -
Joe's Diner The 50 - Haunting Bundle ? Steam thread Apr 29 2019 Keys received from the Groupees support are also duplicates. Keys from IndieGala - Made in Hell Bundle still work.
Jack's Gang Groupees - Build a Bundle 28 - Steam Thread May 02 2019 -
Obscure Realm Groupees - Build A Greenlight Bundle 54 - Once a Steam Thread & StG Comment May 01 2019 Banned on Jul 29
Box Maze Groupees - Build a Bundle 23 - Steam thread Apr 29 2019 -
Box Maze - Halloween Skins Pack Groupees - Build a Bundle 23 - Steam thread Apr 29 2019 -
The Asskickers GreenManGaming & IndieGala Friday Special Bundle #31 Contact GMG Support Steam thread Apr 22 2019 -
Agricultural Simulator 2012: Deluxe Edition IndieGala - The Indie Mosaic Bundle ? SG comment Apr 01 2019 Keys received from IndieGala support (27 Mar 19) don't work either
School Bus Fun IndieGala - The Indie Mosaic Bundle ? SG comment Apr 01 2019 Keys received from IndieGala support (27 Mar 19) don't work either
Industry Giant 2 IndieGala - The Indie Mosaic Bundle ? SG comment Apr 01 2019 Keys from IndieGala - Steel and Giants Bundle still work
Became The Hunted Otaku Bundle #36 ? Steam thread Mar 30 2019 -
Zombie Camp IndieGala - Hump Day Bundle #26 ? SG comment Mar 20 2019 -
Samurai Wars IndieGala - The Postal Party Bundle ? Steam announcement & SG comment Mar 11 2019 There is no complaint thread on Steam yet
Block Smashers IndieGala - Virtual Reality XXVII Bundle ? Steam thread & SG comment - The dev hasn't replied yet
Helicopter Flight Simulator Otaku Bundle Simulators Live Bundle #1 ? SG Comment Feb 28 2019 -
desTRUCKtors: Warfare Showdown Otaku Bundle Simulators Live Bundle #1 ? SG Comment Feb 28 2019 -
Frozen Soul Otaku Bundle Simulators Live Bundle #1 ? SG Comment Feb 28 2019 -
HandyCopter Otaku Bundle Simulators Live Bundle #1 ? SG Comment Feb 28 2019 -
M.I.N.D Go Go Bundle Mega #26 Email to: cosmoticgames@gmail.com or Twitter @kakataja. However, the requested keys haven't been sent out yet Dev comment & Steam thread Feb 17 2019 The dev hasn't replied yet
Through Abandoned: The Underground City Go Go Bundle #48 ? SG comment Feb 10 2019 There is no complaint thread on Steam yet
Through Abandoned 2. The Forest Go Go Bundle #48 Email to: igor@krutovig.com Steam thread & SG comment Feb 10 2019 -
A Salem Witch Trial Go Go Bundle Undated #9 & IndieGala - Monday Motivation Bundle #54 - SG comment Steam thread Feb 10 2019 There is no complaint thread on Steam yet
Neckbeards: Basement Arena Otaku Bundle #31 - SG comment Feb 09 2019 There is no complaint thread on Steam yet
Flat Kingdom Paper's Cut Edition Humble Jumbo Bundle 11 & IndieGala - The Indiespensable Bundle ? Steam thread Jan 28 2019 Some keys still work.
Inexistence Otaku Bundle #21 & IndieGala - The Indiespensable Bundle - Steam thread & SG comment Jan 27 2019 The dev hasn't replied yet
Firewood Otaku Bundle #30 ? Steam thread Jan 12 2019 -
Firewood Soundtrack Otaku Bundle #30 ? Steam thread Jan 12 2019 -
A-Gents Groupees - Be Mine 25 & IndieGala - Friday Special #36 - Steam thread Jan 06 2019 Keys from GameBundle - The Labor Day GameBundle still work
Video Blogger Story IndieGala - The Secret Octagon Bundle info@5wolf.ru; prensa@5wolf.ru Steam Thread Nov 22 2018 -
Solenars Edge Heroes IndieGala - Barbarian Taco Bundle - Dev comment Jul 07 2018 Dev says he can't generate more keys.
Overhell Groupees - Build a Bundle #26 - Steam Thread Jun 12 2018 -
Sixtieth Kilometer IndieGala - The Indie Xplorer Bundle & Fanatical - Playlist Bundle 3 - Steam thread & SG comment Jun 12 2018 Keys from IndieGala - Anime Wonderland Bundle still work. Keys from Groupees bundles might not work.
Ziggy's Chase IndieGala Hump Day #34 Contact the devs Steam thread & SG comment Mar 13 2018 -
Spirits of Xanadu IndieGala Monday Motivation #15. Email: contact@goodmorningcommander.com Steam thread & SG comment Mar 13 2018 -
Zombie Office Politics Fanatical - Fully Loaded 2 Bundle - Dev announcement Dec 27, 2017 -
Treasure of a Blizzard IndieGala - The Anime Treasure Bundle - SG comment & Steam thread Dec 20 2017 The original complaint thread was deleted from the forum.
Day D: Tower Rush IndieGala - Friday Special #38 ? ? ? -
Running Man 3D Part2 Go Go Bundle Limited #73 ? ? ? Note: according to this, the keys (or some) might still work.
Math Combat Challenge Otaku Bundle #17 & IndieGala- The Indie Wanderlust Bundle Add the developer on Steam to request a new key Steam thread ? -
Divinia Chronicles: Relics of Gan-Ti Groupees Be Mine 24 ? ? ? -
Dexodonex ? ? ? ? -
Mobile Astro IndieGala Friday Slaughter Bundle Email to:RaxasoftGames@gmail.com ? ? -
Pixel Arcade ? ? ? ? -
Plank not included ? ? ? ? -
Dark Mechanism ? ? ? ? -
Distant Nightmare ? ? ? ? -
Escape From Nazi Labs ? ? ? ? -
Mad Dojo ? ? ? ? -
Particulars ? ? ? ? -
Soul Axiom ? ? ? ? -
The Away Team ? ? ? ? -
Gnomes Garden IndieGala The 8FLOOR Bundle & Groupees 8floor Bundle & Groupees Build a 8Floor/Joybits Bundle ? Steam thread Mar 20 2018 -
Solitaire Christmas. Match 2 Cards IndieGala The 8FLOOR Bundle & Groupees 8floor Bundle & Groupees Build a 8Floor/Joybits Bundle ? Steam thread Mar 20 2018 -
Chronicles of the Witches and Warlocks Groupees 8floor Bundle & Groupees Build a 8Floor/Joybits Bundle ? Full list & Steam thread Mar 20 2018 Keys from IndieGala The 8FLOOR Bundle still work
Gems of the Aztecs IndieGala The 8FLOOR Bundle & Groupees 8floor Bundle & Groupees Build a 8Floor/Joybits Bundle ? Full list & Steam thread Mar 20 2018 -
Gnumz: Masters of Defense IndieGala The 8FLOOR Bundle & Groupees 8floor Bundle & Groupees Build a 8Floor/Joybits Bundle ? Full list & Steam thread Mar 20 2018 -
Contract With The Devil IndieGala The 8FLOOR Bundle & Groupees 8floor Bundle & Groupees Build a 8Floor/Joybits Bundle ? Full list ? -
Portal of Evil: Stolen Runes Collector's Edition IndieGala The 8FLOOR Bundle & Groupees 8floor Bundle & Groupees Build a 8Floor/Joybits Bundle ? Full list & Steam thread ? -
Royal Defense IndieGala The 8FLOOR Bundle & Groupees 8floor Bundle & Groupees Build a 8Floor/Joybits Bundle ? Full list & Steam thread Mar 20 2018 -
Fort Defense IndieGala The 8FLOOR Bundle & Groupees 8floor Bundle & Groupees Build a 8Floor/Joybits Bundle ? Full list & Steam thread Mar 20 2018 -
AoF World Online ? - Steam thread Mar 15 2018 The game was completely removed from the store.
One Night Groupees - Be Afraid Bundle - SG comment & Steam forum Mar 29 2016 The game was retired from Steam.
Days Under Custody The Mixcellaneous Bundle - SG Thread & SG comment Mar 21 2016 -

Games which were completely removed from your library

Game Bundles affected What can you do? Related threads & comments Revocation / Reported Date Notes
HOT VIEW ECCHI GIRLS giveaway.su - Steam Thread & Dev explanation
Jun 12 2019 -
Z: Escape Go Go Bundle Limited #79 Email to ervenstar.games@gmail.com Steam thread Jun 04 2019 Keys will not be replaced. The game will become F2P.
Achievement Collector: Cat Giveaway.su ? Steam thread Apr 30 2019 -
Dumb Stone Otaku Bundle #37 ? Steam thread (there are several others) Apr 05 2019 -
Dojini Go Go Bundle Limited #79 Email to: bajogamess@gmail.com Dev thread & deleted Steam thread & SG comment & GroupBuy comment Apr 02 2019 Keys from Bunch Keys Bundle #30: Gaming Heaven were not affected.
Neon Sun Go Go Bundle Limited #54 Email to: excellente23@yandex.ru Steam thread & SG comment Mar 20 2019 -
Wanderer of Teandria Groupees - Build A Greenlight Bundle 35 Dev will not send keys any more Steam thread Mar 07 2019 The complaint thread was closed.
No70: Eye of Basir Groupees - Build a Bundle #42 Email to: info@no70game.com. New keys have also been distributed to Groupees Dev comment SG Thread 6 Mar 2019 Replacement keys were added to your Groupees purchase
Hotel Anatolia DIG Point Store and maybe others Email to: theelvenworkshop@gmail.com Steam thread Feb 28 2019 The stores were not authorized to resell these keys
Ghoulboy Go Go Bundle #56 and Fanatical - Hidden Gems 7 Bundle and Otaku Bundle #20 Email to: serkanbakar81@gmail.com Dev comment & SG Thread 1 & SG Thread 2 & SG Thread 3 Feb 13 2019 -
iterform Otaku Bundle #35 The dev doesn't seem to be willing to send replacement keys: "If the game really worth it for you, you can buy it via Steam, it's on a huge sale now. If it's not, so be it." Steam thread & Dev comment & SG thread Jan 14 2019 Keys from IndieGala - Midsummer Indie Bundle seem to still work
The path to domination Otaku Bundle #35 Email to: seaborgiumentertainment@mail.ru SG thread Jan 03 2019 -
Typical Nightmare Otaku Bundle #36 Email to: EvilGamesStudios@yandex.ru. You must use a specific format for your message (see this) Steam thread (in Russian though) & SG thread Jan 02 2019 The complaint thread from the game's forum has been closed
Not my day Otaku Bundle #36 Email to: EvilGamesStudios@yandex.ru. You must use a specific format for your message (see this) Steam thread & SG thread Jan 02 2019 The complaint thread from the game's forum has been closed
Outside Otaku Bundle #36 Email to: EvilGamesStudios@yandex.ru. You must use a specific format for your message (see this) SG thread Jan 02 2019 -
Simple Story - Alex + DLCs Go Go Bundle Limited #75 ? Dev comment & SG thread Dec 14 2018 The complaint thread from the game's forum has been deleted. DLC removed: Find Exit (Simple Story - Alex DLC) , Simple Story Alex - Two Guys, Simple Story Alex - Good Day, Simple Story - Alex: Beer Donation for developer
johnsgame June Cubic Bundle Vol. 2 or DIG - Steam thread Nov 25 2017 -
Nekro Groupees Be Mine 13 - SG Thread Sep 18 2014 The game is not available on Steam any more.
Broken Armor IndieGala - Indie Quest Bundle ? ? ? -
Bulby - Diamond Course IndieGala - Indie Mental Bundle ? ? ? -
Westboro Keys bought from the IndieGala Store were revoked ? SG thread ? -
Shakedown Racing One IndieGala - Friday Special #30 ? ? ? -
Porradaria Upgrade Bundle Kings - Super Bundle ? Dev comment ? Keys revoked because they were from a giveaway
Porradaria Upgrade Bundle Kings - Bonus Bundle ? Dev comment ? Keys revoked because they were from a giveaway
FoxyLand Groupees - Build a Bundle #37 ? ? ? -
Butsbal Indie Royale - The Debut 26 Bundle ? ? ? -
Insanely Twisted Shadow Planet Go Go Bundle Undated #9 ? SG Thread ? -
Insanely Twisted Shadow Planet Otaku Bundle #12 ? SG Thread ? -
Survival: Last Day IndieGala - Indie Road Trip Bundle ? SG thread ? -
Urban War Defense IndieGala - The Twinkly Twelve Bundle & Groupees - Build a Greenlight Bundle 7 ? SG thread ? -
George's Memories Ep.1 Go Go Bundle Limited #79 ? Feb 06 2019 ? -
Freedom Defender Go Go Bundle Mega #14 ? SG Comment ? -
Porradaria 2 - Vladmirson Bundle Kings - Bonus Bundle ? ? ? -

DMCA

Jerry McPartlin - Rebel with a Cause | Groupees - (Sometimes) Thursday Bundle #9 & Fanatical - Hidden Gems 3 Bundle & IndieGala - The Indie Mosaic Bundle

A warm thank you goes to everyone who contributed to this thread. You folks are awesome!

7 months ago*

Comment has been collapsed.

Nice

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

About Ghoulboy - here is info from dev (https://steamcommunity.com/app/752500/discussions/0/1781640738624917537/) in short send mail with purchase confirmation

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I got two Ghoulboy keys revoked. 1 was replaced pretty fast, the other is still not (tried Feb. 13th).

However it seems the developer is replacing agan. Maybe my mail got lost somewhere?

Edit: Did write a new mail - and got a replacement key.

7 months ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

<3

edit: Lilly, why not adding also a template for your table, so we can contribute (and maybe helping you a little?) +more <3

7 months ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Thanks for the suggestion!
Here's the template:

Game | Bundles affected | What can you do? | Related threads & comments | Revocation Date | Notes
:- | :- | :- | :- | :- | :-
GAME_NAME | BUNDLE_LIST | DEV_EMAIL | THREADS_LIST | REVOCATION_DATE | ANY_OTHER_INFO

Edit: I will also need to know if it's "completely revoked" or "the unused keys have been invalidated".

7 months ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Really useful thread, sensualshakti. Especially if count how often it takes place recently...

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

This is actually not a bad idea for a topic. Should really be pinned so we all know what's going on. But you know that people will still make multiple topics on it anyway.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

people will still make multiple topics on it anyway

but now we have something to link, simply shooting a comment, like:

"hey, could you please contribute here --> https://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/Dgscb/ <-- ?"

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I have not yet? been affected by any of those revocations, but I think adding the date of revocation would be a useful addition to your table.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Nice addition.
Also I'd like to see which specific site was involved in the revoking, I myself don't know that "Build a bundle" is Groupees as the operator e.g.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Good idea! I added a date column, but for the keys that are invalidated i will probably leave it empty (or list an approximate date, when the first report occured).

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

This isn't exactly recent but it happened a couple months ago.

Electro Stalin Entertainment revoked all keys from Otakumaker for the games Typical Nightmare, Not my Day and Outside.

Lugum created a thread about it which also has a fix.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Game | Revocation type | Bundles affected | What can you do? | Related threads & comments | Notes
:- | :- | :- | :- | :- | :-
[M.I.N.D](https://store.steampowered.com/app/825620/) | The unused keys have been invalidated | [Go Go Bundle Mega #26](https://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/OHp7R/gogobundle-go-go-bundle-mega-26-unused-keys-for-mind-have-been-disabled) | [Dev say you can Mail him invalid keys to cosmoticgames@gmail.com but until now nothing happens](https://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/OHp7R/gogobundle-go-go-bundle-mega-26-unused-keys-for-mind-have-been-disabled#5lYT3yG) | [SG Go Go Bundle Mega #26 Thread](https://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/OHp7R/gogobundle-go-go-bundle-mega-26-unused-keys-for-mind-have-been-disabled) / [Steam Thread](https://steamcommunity.com/app/825620/discussions/0/3658515990054235952/) | The dev hasn't replied yet
7 months ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

If you put ``` above and below your post then sensualshakti can easily copy it and add it to the main table.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Thanks, missed it :)

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

wurstbrot

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Käsebrot :D

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Nutellabrot!

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Awesome, many thanks!

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Of course, it's mainly IndieGala.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Didn't know it was this bad until I saw the chart. I haven't bought an IndieGala bundle in ages, not even a GroupBuy. How they're somehow still alive is kind of a mystery to me.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Actually, it's mostly Otaku (and GogoBundle, which is the same thing). Indiegala doesn't have that much revoked, and it doesn't appear that those issues are anything like Otaku, which just simply stopped playing devs for games in the last bundles they supplied. I lost about 30 keys in that mess. B@stards.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Yeah, around 17 from Indiegala and 30 from Otaku + GoGoBundle. Didn't know those two were connected. If they weren't, then the numbers would point at Indiegala again though. Not to mention all the accounts getting just revoked for "inactivity", which is basically hundreds of keys lost there too.

But it definitely shows how the lower end bundle sites are the ones to have those controversies. Another reason not to support them.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Indiegala is usually pretty solid. I've had to reach out to their support on more than one occasion. While they were kind of slow, they fixed my issues (including issuing new keys) in all cases except for one (and that was a dev who supplied some already-used keys...some worked, some didn't, and indiegala ran out of valid replacements...nothing they could do at that point, and I had to try to contact the dev, who was shady and did nothing). I've found that most of the issues with keys that came through IG were because of the dev shop, not IG itself. Still, because they're dealing with a lot smaller shops on average, your chances of having an issue are higher. But at least they've always paid the devs that they deal with. :)

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

interesting, I activated many of those games from those indiegala bundles and the only one ever got revoked from me what I got from IG was Urban War Defense.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Thanks, Lilly. You've gone above and beyond once again. :)

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

you're the best!!
thank you so much, we have been all having lots of problems not only for gogo/otakubundles but also for keys coming from other sites, mass revoked by the developers and so on.. it happened also with fanatical or indiegala if I remember well..
so such a thread is extremely useful to all of us who do many giveaways and also activate lots of games and all of a sudden we see a game revoked without any reason.. thanks a lot again for all your awesome work!

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Added, thank you!

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Death Penalty: Beginning, here's the discussion about it:
https://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/22gtG/revoked-game-death-penalty-beginning

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Thank you, Lilly. Great addition to the forums!

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Replacement keys for No70: Eye of Basir have been added to your Groupees account, at least it is in mine now!

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Many thanks for this thread. Really useful so people can be kept updated especially if they have bought lots of otaku bundles. Great work and keep it up Shakti :-)

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

i'm very sad for ghoulboy ;( i get this game because i want play sor of "black tiger" game but black tiger not have in the steam store so i get ghoulboy , but ok never mind when\if i can i will re-get it on the steam store ;(
edit: Thank you so much for this thread

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Through Abandoned | The unused keys have been invalidated | Go Go Bundle #48 | [SG Thread](https://www.steamgifts.com/go/comment/zK4QIUJ) | ?
Through Abandoned 2. The Forest | The unused keys have been invalidated | Go Go Bundle #48 | [SG Thread](https://www.steamgifts.com/go/comment/zK4QIUJ) | ?
7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Thank you! 🌞

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I contacted the dev over a bad key for Through Abadoned from the Fanatical Vigilante bundle (from BundleStars, at the time). He replaced the key promptly, and said that he had not bulk-revoked keys at any time. He checked the key I was not able to use and told me that it had been activated in April of 2018. Of course he might have just not been telling the truth, but ultimately I was uncertain what was going on.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

You always get the revoke message from Steam when this happens, right? You know, that alert message saying one of your games has been revoked etc. So far i got this only for alphas/betas that ended and the devs cancelled the keys. Hope it stays that way.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Just a suggestion: Can you add the name of the website to the "bundles affected" column ? Like "Groupees Build a Bundle #666" instead of "Build a Bundle #666" It would make it easier to search e.g. for all groupees bundle (or indiegala).

A "website" column would be best, but I understand that it's impossible, with Ghoulboy revoked in three different bundles.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Yep, I will do that.
If one game has been revoked from multiple bundles, would it be better to have one row for each bundle (without repeating the whole info, but only the game name and the bundle? Or would it be more confusing this way?

Game Revocation type Bundles affected What can you do? Related threads & comments Revocation Date Notes
Ghoulboy Completely revoked Go Go Bundle #56 and Fanatical - Hidden Gems 7 Bundle and Otaku Bundle #20 Contact the devs: serkanbakar81@gmail.com Dev comment & SG Thread 1 & SG Thread 2 & SG Thread 3 Feb 13 2019 -

vs

Game Revocation type Bundles affected What can you do? Related threads & comments Revocation Date Notes
Ghoulboy Completely revoked Go Go Bundle #56 Contact the devs: serkanbakar81@gmail.com Dev comment & SG Thread 1 & SG Thread 2 & SG Thread 3 Feb 13 2019 -
Ghoulboy Completely revoked Fanatical - Hidden Gems 7 Bundle - - - -
Ghoulboy Completely revoked Otaku Bundle #20 - - - -
7 months ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

That's a good question, I would settle for the second one, possible with "see above" on the "Notes" column (or What can you do)

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

While the second option is better if you want to know which games from a bundle have been revoked, I clearly prefer the first option which is more compact and don't have multiple entries for the same game.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

First option is way more clear.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

First option is better, keeps the table more compact while still have all the info

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

first one.

also: for "What can you do" column you may should add a link to a comment instead of multiple lines of text, so to not have a veeery taaaall table? like, keeping it "compact" should be easy to read, imo (thanks again, and again)

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

The links to dev comments / other threads open on the same topic or any other info that I could find is listed in the "Related threads & comments"
I don't like the length of the column either, but that's also because you can't set a custom width to a column, therefore all of them have the same width. As a consequence, the more columns you have, the narrower they become.
When I started the thread, I had no idea that there were so many games revoked. I was expecting 10-20 maybe, therefore I added the "Revocation type" column. Considering how many rows that table will have in the end, I think it's better to split it into 2 charts: one for games that are revoked from your library, the other one for games whose unused keys were disabled. This way, we eliminate redundant info and gain some more space for the columns :)
We'll see how it goes from there and what other adjustments we can make.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

the more columns you have, the narrower they become

true that, forgot it.
clever idea, splitting it in two charts. now it's on all of us helping you helping us, like -again- following a template for contributions :D

(pretty sure this page will be also used outside SG. the whoooole Internet is kissing you!)

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Thank you for you work on this!

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

The fact that a list had to be made to keep track of revoked keys from developers is appalling.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Indeed, Steam really has to end this.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Useful info Thanks

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Wow, seeing all of them in a single place makes you realise how much there is. I guess it's becoming a thing now...

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

i am not affected by these (yet). Yet! Because the only bundle I've bought from Otaku was the HeroCraft Bundle. I still have the keys from that bundle but the furor of recent revocation. I've not given them out. Thank you very much for your effort and thoughts of the community for this thread its very useful indeed!. Cheers, Cruse~

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sign in through Steam to add a comment.