Valid reason for reroll?

Talk with the person who won and if he is good with the re roll go for it , otherwise u might be in trouble.

You have to give the key.

No reroll here. Either send it to him or live with "not received" in your profile.
You can blacklist him if you think he's a prick, but nothing to do with this particular giveaway.

First it´s no reason for reroll if someone did not play his games in the past....or even if he would not play the new one.
Second....don´t trust those numbers to much....steams shows for some games i played through three times nearly zero playtime....

The number of games an user owns and the time they have played cannot be grounds for a reroll.

You'll need to just give it to him. Sadly he won fair and square. Just blacklist him for the future! Maybe make a private giveaway and post in the forums saying you would only like people who are interested in playing the game... Otherwise, there isn't much you can do :/

I don't think that's a valid reason for a re-roll, but you bought the game and ultimately it's your decision to send it or not. Though he'll have to mark it as not received if you don't. I guess you have to decide which is worse. :D

I also had this problem. I made a giveaway of my favorite game. A guy won it. He has over 1000 games. He never played it I also had a friend and I gave him a game. He never played it. I told him to refund it. He lied. He said he did but didn't. I blocked him and remove him. It's annoying!

What you're saying is making as much sense as not being able to regift, ie it doesn't make sense. Yet it's in the rules whereas your rationale isn't, so the thing to do is follow rules.
Then again I'm blacklisted by you, which I just found out and that makes no sense to me either.

I can sympathise as I have looked at a few winners and had slightly similar feelings - but support wouldn't agree those were valid reasons for a re-roll. And also keep in mind steam stats also aren't the whole story. I have nothing like 2,500 games and I hope I have better playtimes than the user you mentioned - but I do travel a lot and have played a lot of games on my laptop in offline mode without registering time played or achievements and I try to take into account that other users might be doing similar things.

Keep in mind this are your own personal rules and not everyone thinks like you, so my advice, create a whitelist or your own group.
Or maybe if you had asked on the GA description, he wouldn't have entered.
What perplexes me is your assumption that he wouldn't play it.

When in doubt, make a support ticket and ask a official SG moderator if your reason(s) are a valid reason(s) for a reroll.

Not a valid reason as per the rules.

If the person entered your giveaway, they are at least slightly interested. The guy put down points to enter your giveaway, same as everyone else on the site. How does the number of games he owns have any bearing on whether or not he wants to play one specific one? I have over 1500 games. A good chunk of them just came in bundles along with games that I actually wanted, and I've never touched a lot of those side games that came in the bundles. But when I enter for a game here, it's not bundled with something else I want. I'm actively expressing interest in that one game.

If you were just talking about games he's won here, and if he hasn't played any of them, that might have some merit to it. But to say you don't want to give him a game just because he doesn't play his bundle scraps? What kind of logic is that?

Also, I just checked and of your eighteen wins, you have only played seven. That leaves 60% of them that you've never even touched. Hello, kettle? This is pot. I just wanted to tell you that you're looking a little black today.

This is subjective, just your personal opinion. Give the guy the game, the rules are there to be followed.

Your giveaway looks like it was Level 3+ so, at least he's paid it forward.

I have 1.5k games and I'd hate to be told by the creator of a GA that he wants to reroll my win because I 'have to many games.'

If you want to restrict the people who can enter your giveaways, then create a whitelist or steam group. In this case you are obligated to follow through on your gift. The only legit way to get out of it is if you talk to the person and get them to agree to a reroll (as in, get them to post a comment in your GA saying it is ok to reroll). But otherwise, the winner is entitled to receive the gift and they are not obligated to agree to a reroll.

Your personal feelings about the winner isn't a valid reason for a reroll. You should make invite only giveaways or join a specific steam group if you're not feeling ok with making public giveaways. That way your games won't go to unworthy receivers.

Not sure why number of games matters that much. I mean, I have almost 3000 games, but like 3/4 of the games are bundle fodder that I never planned to play anyways - I bought the bundle, so is it bad that I want to recoup some of the cost by getting the card drops and stopping there?

You still have to give the game. It sucks, but he won fair and square. If you don't like people with many games winning, your only refuge is blacklisting them and moving on.

However, I'd urge you to consider that having lots of games doesn't mean people don't want to play particular games. For example, I have over 2000+ games in my library (too lazy to check profile on this crappy hotel wifi that doesn't let me log into steam because the network is too weak) but I've accumulated those over seven+ years and the majority of games I haven't played are bundle trash that I picked up through other bundles. There are some games that I enter for here that I would play in an heartbeat, perhaps for many many hours. The number of games I own doesn't matter. That said, perhaps you might not mind someone like me with tons of hours on Steam, though I am definitely guilty of idling..

unfortunately as everony else said, you'll have to send the game, unless you want a "not sent" mark on you.

You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink.
At least you can try to add him to your friendlist and invite to play together.

Well the playtime isn't always something you should look. For example, if you look my profile you can see 7 hours(or something like that) on Sniper Elite but I actually played more than 10 but offline, I played maybe 70 hours on Insurgency and Counter Strike but offline and you can only see a part when I was logged. Yeah sure, that profile you saw It's just one for farming cards but in the future if you find someone with 1000 games and low play hours it's maybe just because he doesn't have a connection all the time. ;)

You can not reroll it, but you can blacklist him if you want, preventing him from future wins.

You can ask him. If he agree, than you can reroll.
If not, you should give him the key.