Best Humble Bundle?

Since i already had SR3 before it was a bundle game, I think the Origin bundle has been the best.

I can't decide...

THQ Bundle is good and the Origin Bundle

Hard to say, but it was good Telltale Games bundle.

deep silver and origin, can not decide

It's a tie for me between the HIB V and the THQ bundle. I haven't played much of the Origin bundle yet because I'm still working on the Deep Silver bundle!

THQ

Can't decide. I guess it depends on what kind of games you play.
I liked THQ and Origin a lot, then there was Alan Wake and Bastion.
Telltale was so cool, especially for adventure lovers.
Really, I can't decide :))

My first bundle is Origin,but i think that THQ was better.

V.

I can't decide!!! V was my first and I just HAD to have it for Psychonauts. 7 probably has the most games that I've played and enjoyed especially since that one had Binding of Isaac. THQ and Origin are pretty awesome for the AAA games, but I play on a laptop that don't run most of them (you'd all laugh at me playing Darksiders considering my high lag toleration)

Humble Bundle 4. EVERY game in it was awesome, plus it came with Humble Bundle 3 as an extra.

5 is nearly tied.

THQ was the best, along with Double Fine bundle.

Deep silver is the one ive spent more time playing so i think this is my favorite, but origin was pretty good with awesome games, and THQ was fun, maybe the weekly alan wake one was pretty good too! i dont know XD

Price-wise, I would say the Origin Bundle.
Quality-wise, the Deep Silver & THQ Bundle (tied).

I bought to many, I seem to be missing a few on my account though....

Gotta go with 7.

The one with braid! Still the best indie game so far!!! And with the first humble bundles you received the previous as an extra ;-)

Edit: Hib 2 that is. And got Hib 1 as bonus

THQ, EA.

But the lousy thing is I own everything in these already.

I think you need to qualify in your question whether you're asking about the TRUE Humble Bundle, which doesn't mean all these AAA games. And most AAA games are cliche, as well. At least indie gamers aren't afraid to think outside the box, combine genres etc to get something out that feels fresh and/or new.

As for my pick, I'd probably have a hard time deciding between HiBV and Botanicula for best. (And yes, that's over all the AAA bundles)

Well the Alan Wake bundle was the biggest "WTF!?!" bundle for me, not sure any bundle will ever beat that.

I owned a lot of stuff from the other big bundles (for example, I already owned Burnout, Dead Space and Mirrors Edge prior to the Origin Bundle), so they were kind of a bummer for me.

Best Humble Indie Bundle for me would be HiB 5.. it contained most of the top indie games of the last few years.

Best Humble Bundle of all would probably be the actual Origin Bundle but on another note it has the worst Bonus of all HiB history.

From the list you have, 4 and 5 are the best in my opinion.
From all time bundles, the Origin one.

THQ