As in you've read the books beforehand, and when you watch the movies/TV series/play the games, you want the adaptation to be as close to the books as possible?

Examples: Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings & The Hobbit, Game of Thrones.

Myself, I'm not really sure...I liked the LOTR movies a lot, and even after reading the books (for LOTR it was movies then books), I still liked the LOTR movies, although once having watched the extended edition, it's hard to watch the vanilla versions of the movies. But when it came to Harry Potter, I liked the books a lot more (but I read the books before the movies, with the possible exception of the 1st & 2nd books). Funnily enough, with the Harry Potter games (at least the earlier ones), they were more faithful to the books, such as including Peeves, the garden gnomes at the Burrow etc.

Speaking of which, I've just started on the Game of Thrones series (only watched the pilot episode so I haven't gone too far into it yet), and I'm wondering whether I should read the books first, or continue with the series first (or a combination of both).

1 decade ago*

Comment has been collapsed.

Deleted

This comment was deleted 5 years ago.

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Exactly...it's really important that the producer and the director leaves their prints when turning the book into a movie.

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

The problem is, u watch movies first (HP was good both).

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I am, kinda. Usually I don't like to watch a movie/play a game after I have already read the book. For example, I think that The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a horrible movie. Also, I'm yet to play Metro 2033 and I fear that I might get disppointed(despite everybody saying that is it a great game), because I've already read both Metro 2033 and Metro 2034.
Vice versa is usually OK so If I can, I prefer to watch/play before reading the book.
And, of course, there are some loosely based adaptations like Night Watch and Day Watch movies who has little in common with their respective books. I don't really mind these adaptations because I consider them as two independent instances of a common storyline.

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Yes I am. Most of the time I'm not satified with a novel adaptation to the cinema.

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I generally like a movie to follow the storyline of a book fairly closely like the lord of the rings movies (mostly anyways). I absolutely hate it when a movie just wings it and pulls stuff out of its ass (Eragon..........)

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Scott Pilgrim is the only one I can recall.
Weren't into the other book into movies adaptations.

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Depends on the quality of the adaption, but generally speaking as long as the core ideas behind the story hold up I don't care how different source and adaption are. (Cases in point: Akira the manga vs. Akira the anime, Bladerunner the movie vs. Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep the book, the various versions of the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy which all spawned from the original radio play).
There's always changes required to fit a new medium anyway.

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

case-by-case; sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't.
if it works on its own, while failing the spirit of the original, then yeah, it bothers me if I was already a fan of the original.
for me, spirit is more important than accuracy in adaptations. different mediums have different capabilities and constraints, and I appreciate the creators in those mediums utilizing their strengths and avoiding their weaknesses.

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

No, I accept change as long as its still good or decent even.

Also I like when they change endings or story bits, really its better then seeing the same thing over usually...but many people hate when it does that.

1 decade ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Closed 1 decade ago by QuartzPort.