"Crappy games" you always loved.

Legendary

Ocarina of Time, only 99 metacritic,which is too low of course :p -
On a more serious note, the original Rayman, got only decent scores, but i thought it deserved more

Duke Nukem Forever. Don't know why people keep bashing it.

Postal 2 and Shadowflare!

Spider-Man: Web of Shadows - best spider-man's game on PC for me (didn't play shattered dimensions though). Also Serious Sam 3 (72 on metacritic. I think it's not so much) and Borderlands.

Sonic R. No saturation needed

Postal 2, not crappy but did did get a lot of negative reviews & was slammed for its content

Dark Messiah of Might and Magic. Enjoyed it mainly for battle system, balanced abilities tree and generally good experiense.

Clive Barkers Jericho

mirrors edge!

I've always had a certain love for card based combat games. The Megaman Battle Network series is one of my favorites, but I agree with the general consensus that 3 blows the rest of the series away.

Metal Gear Ac!d was cool too.

No matter how gay people called all the Final Fantasy games i still loved every one of them. :"D FF Fanboy.