What other games would I like?

I also like those 2 games and as mentioned here, games which i said are familiar and i liked them

1. Saints Row 4 (very crazy and funny game)
2. Shadow of Mordor
3. Mad Max
4. Grand Thef Auto V

Maybe: Witcher 1-3, Sleeping Dogs, Fallout 4 and Watch Dogs 1-2

Something a bit different from the other suggestions here (which are pretty great):
Mark of the Ninja
It's quite heavy on 2D stealth, but beautiful gameplay! Not an open world by any means, but each stage has a few hidden rooms and puzzles to solve. Enemies can be distracted, brutally murdered, psychologically traumatized, or completely avoided (except bosses - but even those have multiple different methods to defeat).

Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

Bump !

It could be interesting for you

"metroidvania" is used for about anything nowadays lol

Someone probably mentioned it already but Dishonored maybe? I liked it especially because you can play this game in comepletely different ways (stealth mode or killer mode), depending on what playstyle suits you more.
Oh, and Bioshock Infinite. Just because it's love.

Dragon's Dogma: Dark Arisen - Dragon Age: Origins - Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning™ maybe?
They might not be how exactly u ask but still great games though
i havent played them yet.idk much about it.But they seem cool and i bought them
Otherwise i absolutely recommend Tomb Raider,Witcher,ACreed,Batman,FarCry series and also Skyrim,Shadow of mordor,Mad Max.These all best

Pretty much my favourite kind of game too, I stopped playing the first Arkham game because I had really unreliable broadband at the time and the game would actually quit whenever the connection got dropped :( I really must go back and complete it one day (internet is finally decent now).

They're getting a bit old now (and you've probably played them already?), but I loved all the 3D Legacy of Kain games (Soul Reaver 1 and 2 etc).
I'd also second the recommendations for Dishonored 2 (loved the first one, loved the second too), and the two recent Deus Ex games.
I'm also really enjoying the second Styx game, having finally gotten the first on sale a couple of weeks ago (and enjoyed that). As Mully said they're essentially all stealth, but you usually have an option to fight if you get spotted.

P.S. Thanks for the ESGST giveaways! 🙂

I haven't played very far into it yet, but perhaps Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning? I think it meets many of your requirements and so far it seems pretty fun (with the exception of the dispelling mechanic to remove wards off of chests - hate that part). The full collection also goes on sale for about $10CDN fairly frequently.

Vampire The Masquerade Bloodlines

batman arkham games
Assassin creed 2
Saints row the third
Trine 1 & 2
Alpha Protocol (because why not)

I really liked Tomb Raider (and now RotTR) as it's felt similar to Assassin's Creed.
I played all of them before Unity (as my PC keeps crashing on this one) and I really love them all
I haven't managed to get into the Batman games, although I love him as a Character. But maybe I should try again.

If you don't mind a game wich is technically a bit outdated how about giving Beyond Good & Evil a chance?
It's a great game wich I think fits your listed criteria pretty well and also it is not expensive.

More or less Darksiders 1 and 2, All Batman: Arkham games, Tomb Raider 2013 and Rise of the Tomb Raider, Ori and the Blind Forest - i didn't play it yet but should fit.

I like all kinds of games. But my favorite ones so far would be Saints Row series and Remember Me. And I would highly suggest them to you. Remember Me looked like a different game to me when I played it. ( I don't know if there is a game similar to it... haven't seen any :D) And I love Saints Row series cause it has a great sense of humor.

Skyrim.

I don't understand what do you mean by "on rails" but i'd say Dishonored, Prey and the Witcher but i'll think better if something else comes up onn my mind

deus ex HR and mankind?
hitman?
witcher 3?

I'm pretty late to the party here....but since you ignored it so far in the 3 posts where it was mentioned:
Beyond Good and Evil
Beyond Good and Evil really is a gem of a game with a really lively open world with lots of things to discover inbetween the mainstory missions (in which you have to uncover a big conspiracy) and lots of optional minigames (air hockey-like tablegame, a shell game, racing, hoverboard chases, taking photos of every species, optional map-parts that require simple puzzles solving, combat or stealth) that reward pearls which are required for hovercraft-upgrading and thus reaching previously unreachable parts of the world to advance in the mainstory.
Also I have to mention that it got an amazing soundtrack which really adds to it's atmosphere.

But some of it's stealth sections in the mainmissions are pretty much mandatory to do that way aaaaand the game is now nearly 14 years old....(just in case that is something that would deter you)

Other then that the previously mentioned games of Far Cry 3+4 are really close to the two latest Tomb Raider games, the two newer Deus Ex games fit into this category pretty well too I'd say.

And if you are into completly insane/funny/stupid stories Saints Row 3 + 4 and Just Cause 2 + 3 could also be something you'd lik though they are more like GTA on drugs..

YES, my favorite! Tomb Raider (2013) is my favorite, followed by the Batman: Arkham games and RotTR.

I'd also recommend ENSLAVED: Odyssey to the West and DmC: Devil May Cry (although this one isn't quite up to par with the other games gameplay and story-wise, it has gorgeous combat to make up for it) :D

Will be back to read the other responses when I get the time to do so~!

I'm sort of wondering why I didn't see anyone mention the Demon/Dark Souls games at all based on what you've listed as your interests... They have fairly open(ish) corridor regions where you can decide on multiple routes, at least sometimes, to get from point A to point B. Fighting styles can be varied greatly based on character, equipment, and skill/magic preferences. It's pretty brutal gameplay with lots of dying but can be really rewarding too.
Also the Dead Rising series would fall into this category too, although that's more of a massacre anything coming your way, but one can go about it different ways, choose different routes, etc.
If you don't mind older graphics there's also E.Y.E: Divine Cybermancy, which sort of runs along the lines of Deus Ex-ish FPS type setup where your play style is influenced based on the character class you pick as to whether you approach via stealh, controlling turrets/enemies, straight run n gun or the like.

I don't know... Just Cause? Streets of Rogue? Lords of the Fallen ? Beyond Divinity? Thief 1 ? UnEpic?